Donate Us

Help us keep this free site alive with a small contribution from you. Select an amount below.

Wednesday, March 18, 2026

 


Ali Larijani’s elimination signals a potential turning point in Iran
The elimination of Ali Larijani, the de facto ruler of Iran, alongside that of Gholamreza Soleimani, head of the Basij militia, is not merely another tactical success. It is a strategic turning point—and perhaps something more: an invitation to the Iranian people.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made this explicit in announcing the operation: Israel acted to destabilize the regime to give the Iranian people the opportunity to remove it. “It is your turn,” he told them.

He added a wish to the Iranian people for a new year of freedom. “Our aircraft are hitting the terror operatives on the ground, in the crossroads, in the city squares. This is meant to enable the brave people of Iran to celebrate the Festival of Fire,” Netanyahu said. “So celebrate and Happy Nowruz. We’re watching from above.”

For decades, the Iranian regime has appeared immovable, sustained by repression, fear and a vast machinery of violence. But history teaches us that such systems can collapse suddenly when pressure from above meets courage from below. That moment may now be approaching.

The timing is not incidental. The traditional Zoroastrian fire festival of Chaharshanbe—banned by the regime—offers a symbolic opportunity. Reza Pahlavi has already called on Iranians to go into the streets and light the fires. A gesture that is both cultural and political. A spark that, under the right conditions, can become something larger.

With the removal of Larijani, Israel has struck at one of the regime’s central pillars. After the weakening of Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei’s authority, this represents a second decapitation—one aimed not only at military capability, but at the regime’s political core.


The ‘moderate’ who ran death squads: how BBC and Sky sanitise the Iranian regime
Afew days ago I watched Sky News with amazement as they showed Iranian propaganda images of Ali Larijani walking down the street in Iran on Al Quds Day. They kept commenting how it showed Iranian strength that he was able to walk so freely without fear of assassination, among his people.

I have long been concerned about Sky News' coverage of the Middle East but even I was a bit shocked they appeared to be regurgitating such transparent Islamic Republic propaganda without any hint of intelligent cynicism. So today, when it was announced he was killed by an Israeli strike, my heart went out to Sky News. Perhaps they’ll join the British Foreign Office and ministers at a wake in South Kensington, or at that Islamic Centre opposite my favourite Persian restaurant in London, where they mourned the deaths of Ali Khameini and Qasem Soleimani.

The BBC were no better.

Our national broadcaster’s response managed to go further still, into a kind of analytical absurdity that would be comic if it were not so dangerous. The newsreader, in a tone of concerned moderation, warned of “the slight problem here” that Israel had eliminated figures “considered moderates,” suggesting this might empower “more hardline, less experienced people” and make regime change “more complicated.”

Jeremy Bowen followed: Larijani, he ummed and ahhed, was “seen as a pragmatic figure… a man of flexibility… somebody you can do business with.” Sure, he said “some very tough things, war-like things, in recent weeks,” but who among us hasn’t?

This peculiar BBC effort to rehabilitate an Iranian regime monster is more than a little weird. It takes a man embedded for decades at the core of a coercive theocratic system and recasts him as a regrettable casualty of strategic impatience, a lost interlocutor in some imagined future negotiation. A man who once talked about an "overreaction" to the Holocaust, adding that he was "neither for, nor against" the idea that the Holocaust had really occurred, saying it was an "open question." When did Jeremy Bowen last “do business” with him? Who exactly was doing business with him? Was the BBC? Or did they mean Israel should negotiate how much annihilation it could talk them down to? How many Jews to wipe from the face of the earth? Maybe the Iranian people could negotiate access to water, the Internet, or their relatives if thy just did business with him.


Iranian attack kills man and woman in Ramat Gan, Magen David Adom says
A man and woman were killed by “severe shrapnel injuries” after an Iranian missile hit a residential neighborhood in Ramat Gan in central Israel, Magen David Adom said early on Wednesday morning in Israel.

The emergency service also said that a man in his 20s was being treated for “mild” shrapnel injuries to his hand and being evacuated to the hospital.

Magen David Adom also said that one of its vehicles was “seriously damaged” and an emergency medical technician was “mildly injured.”

United Hatzalah said that it “provided emergency medical treatment following a direct hit on a building in Central Israel.”

“A man and woman in their 70s were pronounced dead at the scene,” it said. “Over 15 others were treated for minor injuries and emotional shock across several locations.”

The Iranian strike caused “severe structural damage to an apartment building and surrounding infrastructure,” according to United Hatzalah.

“Upon arrival, we encountered a scene of extensive devastation,” United Hatzalah medics, who responded to the incident, said. “Tragically, two individuals were found without signs of life within the building. In addition, we provided medical treatment to several other individuals, who sustained light injuries.”


IDF eliminates seven terrorists planning to attack troops in Gaza
The Israel Defense Forces on Sunday struck a Hamas terrorist cell that had been planning an attack on its soldiers, killing seven operatives, including two who infiltrated into Israeli territory during the Oct. 7, 2023, massacre.

Rami Ibrahim Harb and Mutaeb Ziyad Darah, members of Hamas’s Nukhba Force, “infiltrated into Israeli territory during the brutal October 7th massacre,” the military said in its statement on Monday evening.

Other members of the eliminated cell were identified as Abd Muhammad Amtsi—a member of the Popular Resistance Committees that coordinates with Hamas—and Tawfiq Khaldi, a Hamas terrorist.

“Alongside the terrorists, three additional terrorists were eliminated,” it said, adding that troops remain deployed in accordance with the truce deal “and will continue to operate to remove any immediate threat.”

The current Gaza ceasefire went into effect on Oct. 10, 2025, ending the two-year war that started when Hamas, other Palestinian terror groups and Gazan “civilians” invaded the western Negev on Oct. 7, 2023, and slaughtered approximately 1,200 people and kidnapped 251 others.

Representatives of U.S. President Donald Trump’s Board of Peace, that oversees the truce, met with Hamas in Cairo in an attempt to preserve the ceasefire amid the war on Iran, sources told Reuters on Monday.

The three anonymous sources said the Hamas representatives warned the board that the ⁠terror group could renege on past commitments if Israel maintains restrictions on Gaza imposed during the Iran war.


Call me Back Podcast: America’s War Objectives, and Israel’s - with Nadav Eyal and Amit Segal
What happens if the U.S. and Israel win the war militarily, but Iran’s regime survives?

Dan Senor is joined by Nadav Eyal and Amit Segal to assess where the war stands as it enters its third week. While U.S. and Israeli forces continue grinding down Iranian military infrastructure, the bigger questions are now economic and strategic, especially after Iran effectively weaponized the Strait of Hormuz and global energy markets.

They debate whether Washington and Jerusalem share the same endgame, what success would actually look like, and whether removing Iran’s enriched uranium stockpile could become the decisive turning point.

In this episode:
09:12 — The Current Phase of the War: Grinding Through Iranian Targets
09:42 — Iran’s Energy Gambit and the Strait of Hormuz Crisis
11:03 — Oil Markets, Global Pressure, and Trump’s Political Timeline
25:18 — The Strategic Debate Inside Washington and Jerusalem
28:00 — Israel’s Ultimate Goal: Regime Change in Tehran
30:48 — Could the U.S. End the War Before Israel Is Finished?
35:18 — The Enriched Uranium Question and the “Strategic Surprise” Scenario
37:00 — If the Regime Survives: Did the War Actually Change the Region?


Commentary Podcast: Failure to Launch
FDD's Jonathan Schanzer joins us on this St. Patrick's Day to discuss Israel degrading Iran's missile capabilities, as well as the developing Lebanese front. We also discuss the killing of Ali Larijani, the reports that Iran's new supreme leader is gay, and the open questions of whether Iranian proxies in Iraq and Yemen might join the fray.
Joe Kent resigns from top counterterrorism post, citing conspiracies over Israel’s role in Iran war
Joe Kent, director of the National Counterterrorism Center, resigned from his role on Tuesday over opposition to the war in Iran, baselessly alleging that Israel had coerced the United States into what he characterized as a misguided military conflict.

In a letter to President Donald Trump shared on social media, Kent, a former Green Beret who had reported to Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, wrote that he “cannot in good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran,” claiming that the Islamic Republic “posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.”

Kent, a hard-right former congressional candidate in Washington State who has pushed an isolationist foreign policy vision, has previously drawn scrutiny for promoting conspiracy theories, echoing pro-Russia messaging and associating with white supremacists and neo-Nazis, among other controversies.

During a failed House bid in 2022, Kent also said that accepting donations from pro-Israel lobbying groups like AIPAC puts Israel’s “interests ahead of ours” — invoking an antisemitic trope about foreign influence over American politics that is increasingly common on the far right.

Kent’s wife, Heather Kaiser, is a military veteran who has written for The Grayzone, an extremist outlet, authoring articles with its founder Max Blumenthal, a prominent conspiracy theorist who has published sympathetic coverage of Iran and spread misinformation about the Hamas terror attacks of Oct. 7, 2023.

In his letter, Kent claimed that Trump had been tricked into striking Iran by “high-ranking Israeli officials and influential members of the American media” who “deployed a misinformation campaign that wholly undermined” the president’s “America First platform and sowed pro-war sentiments to encourage war with Iran.”
Seth Mandel: Joe Kent Was a Problem of Trump’s Own Making
His resignation letter is a remarkable document, perfect for the right-wing’s podcast-bro laziness and Jews-on-the-brain paranoia.

“Early in this administration, high-ranking Israeli officials and influential members of the American media deployed a misinformation campaign that wholly undermined your America First platform and sowed pro-war sentiments to encourage a war with Iran,” Kent writes. “This echo chamber was used to deceive you into believing that Iran posed an imminent threat to the United States, and that should you strike now, there was a clear path to swift victory. This was a lie and is the same tactic the Israelis used to draw us into the disastrous Iraq war that cost our nation the lives of thousands of our best men and women.”

It’s as if somebody wrote a resignation letter twenty years ago and then put it on ice for just the right moment.

Obviously Trump is untroubled by losing someone with Kent’s sparkling personality and airtight judgment. “I always thought he was a nice guy, but I always thought he was weak on security, very weak,” Trump told reporters, according to the Hill. “When I read his statement I realized it’s a good thing that he’s out, because he said Iran is not a threat. … Every country realized what a threat Iran was.”

This is, of course, not about whether Iran is a threat. Kent is applying for membership in the microphone muftis, the conservative podcasters obsessed with Israel.

But it is worth pointing out that while Trump is obviously on the right side of this argument with Kent, the whole affair is still a consequence of Trump’s own antics—his atrocious behavior on January 6, 2021; his rewarding of those who backed the Capitol riot, thereby incentivizing the GOP to run and nominate loons like Kent; and his decision to staff various national-security offices with loyalists whose suspicion of establishment agencies outweighed their analytical rigor.

The result is that you end up with an administration staffed by people like Joe Kent, who are wholly unqualified for national-security jobs and who may be undermining their policy shop during wartime. It’s to everyone’s benefit that Trump can clear the tinfoil hat brigade out of government when he wants to. Now he just needs to pick up that pace—and stop hiring such folks to begin with.
‘It’s a Good Thing He’s Out’: Top Counterterrorism Official Resigns Following Four Terror Attacks on Homeland, Blaming Israel
Kent's resignation letter echoed statements from fringe figures who have sought to argue that Israel dragged the United States into war with Iran. Tucker Carlson, an isolationist podcaster, has said he has a close relationship with Kent and views him as one of the few non-interventionists who has "some ability to change the country's orientation on foreign policy."

Neo-Nazi Holocaust denier Nick Fuentes said Kent, who mounted two failed congressional campaigns in 2022 and 2024, reached out privately seeking Fuentes's support during his House race.

"I'm on the phone with Joe, and I said, 'Look, we support you, and we want to do everything we can to help you. We want to have my followers knock on doors for you. We want to boost your social media. Anything that you need, we want to help you,'" Fuentes recounted to Tucker Carlson in an interview last year.

"I said, and we don't even want to be publicly associated, I said, because we know that that might hurt you," Fuentes added. "The only thing that we ask in return is you can't disavow me if the media asks, and you can say whatever you need to say, but you can't disavow."

Kent acknowledged in 2022 that he had a phone meeting with Fuentes about the campaign. However, he said the two never entered into an agreement and said he wasn't aware of Fuentes's anti-Semitic and racist views.

The media highlighted Kent's fondness for conspiracy theories and ties to extremists when he was nominated. Those views were downplayed when he broke with Trump on Tuesday. A New York Times article on Kent's confirmation battle in July described him in the opening paragraph as a "contentious choice to be the nation's top counterterrorism official" who "has embraced conspiracy theories and had links to extremist groups." A report on his resignation casts him as a credible advocate for "a more restrained foreign policy inside the administration," making a brief mention of his "penchant for conspiracy theories" in the 10th paragraph.

Kent says in his letter that his late wife Shannon, a Navy cryptologist who died in Syria in 2019, perished "in a war manufactured by Israel." She was one of four Americans killed by a suicide bomber at a popular American restaurant in Aleppo. ISIS took credit for the attack.

While Kent claimed the Syrian civil war was "manufactured by Israel," the United States, under President Barack Obama, intervened in the conflict years before Israel became involved. The conflict broke out in 2011 after mass public uprisings against Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad spiraled into a civil war that eventually involved ISIS. Israel maintained a policy of strict neutrality in Syria until 2017, three years after the United States was embroiled in the conflict.

Kent's current wife, Heather Kaiser, has written for the Grayzone, an anti-war publication that has a pro-Assad and pro-Russia editorial line. The website's managing editor reportedly received payments from the Iranian state-run news network PressTV, according to the Washington Post.

In 2023, she wrote an article based on her own "independent audit" of U.S. aid to Kyiv during the Russia-Ukraine war. The report questioned a "series of wasteful, highly unusual expenditures."


Extremist Yesterday, Authority Today: Media Whitewashes Joe Kent
Within hours of publishing his resignation letter on X, Joe Kent, the Director of the National Counterterrorism Center, had reached millions.

The media, predictably, was enthralled.

“‘Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation’: Trump-appointed intelligence official resigns over Iran war,” CNN blared.

Axios followed suit, presenting Kent’s claims with little skepticism: “‘No imminent threat’: U.S. Counterterrorism Center head resigns over Iran war.”

The Hill amplified another conspiratorial voice, headlining Tucker Carlson’s warning that “neocons” would now try to destroy Kent.

The New York Times published multiple pieces within hours, including one that packaged his resignation letter as a standalone piece.

Readers were invited to see Kent’s words as a serious, insider indictment of both the war against Iran and President Donald Trump’s administration itself.


Onetime Democratic critics elevate Joe Kent’s conspiratorial resignation letter
Some congressional Democrats who previously criticized Joe Kent, the former director of the National Counterterrorism Center, for his extremist history are now elevating his conspiratorial resignation statement in which he blamed Israel for bringing the U.S. into the war with Iran, as well as a series of other Middle East conflicts.

Meanwhile, Republicans who supported Kent during his nomination process are now criticizing the former administration official.

Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA), the vice chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said during Kent’s confirmation process that Kent had a “consistent pattern of questionable judgment and false statements” and willful ignorance to evidence that conflicted with his preexisting political biases and that he had “aligned himself with political violence, promoted falsehoods that undermine our democracy and tried to twist intelligence to serve a political agenda.”

On Tuesday, however, Warner echoed Kent’s comments in his resignation letter, where he wrote that Iran “posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.”

“On this point, he is right: there was no credible evidence of an imminent threat from Iran that would justify rushing the United States into another war of choice in the Middle East,” Warner said. “Ignoring the facts to pursue a predetermined war puts American lives at risk and undermines our national security. The United States cannot be led into conflict on the basis of politics, impulse, or a president’s desire for confrontation. We have seen where this road leads before.”

At the same time, Warner also maintained that Kent’s record is “deeply troubling” and that he should not have been confirmed.

Every Senate Democrat opposed Kent’s confirmation last year.


This summary is not available. Please click here to view the post.

Sunday, March 15, 2026

 

Integralism is back. 

You may not have heard the word, but you've seen its effects — in the post-liberal intellectual movement, in the Heritage Foundation's ideological realignment, in the network of thinkers who've concluded that liberal democracy doesn't just need reform, it needs replacement.

Integralism is not a new idea. It emerged from 19th and early 20th century European Catholic political thought, where traditionalist thinkers argued that civil governments had an obligation to operate under the authority of the Church — that the liberal separation of church and state was not a neutral arrangement but an active political error, a usurpation of the proper order of things. Its most visible expressions were associated with authoritarian regimes in Spain, Portugal, and Latin America. After the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s, the Church itself moved toward affirming religious liberty, which put official Church teaching at odds with integralism's core claims. The ideology retreated to the margins of academic theology, where it remained for decades.

The revival began quietly around 2012, when Oxford philosopher Thomas Pink argued that the Church had never actually abandoned its pre-conciliar political theology — that Vatican II had been misread. By the mid-2010s a small group of American academics had developed a modern version of the argument. The leading figures were Adrian Vermeule, a Harvard constitutional law professor; Patrick Deneen, a Notre Dame political theorist; Chad Pecknold, a theologian at Catholic University; and journalist Sohrab Ahmari. Their online home was a website called The Josias, where integralist political theory was developed and debated in relative obscurity.

Then the political disruption of the 2016 Trump election created a new audience for root-cause critiques of liberal democracy. Deneen's 2018 book Why Liberalism Failed became a significant seller in conservative intellectual circles. At this point the movement made a strategic decision: change the name. "Integralism" carried historical associations with European fascism and antisemitism that made it politically toxic in an American context. The movement's own leaders documented the transition, experimenting with "political Catholicism" and "Christian realism" before settling on "postliberalism" — a label that described what they opposed rather than what they proposed, and sounded considerably less radical. By 2021, Vermeule, Deneen, and their allies had completed the rebrand with a Substack newsletter called Postliberal Order.

Not every postliberal is an integralist. Postliberalism is a wider tent, encompassing Protestant nationalists, Orbán admirers, and various critics of liberal proceduralism who have no particular commitment to Catholic political theology. But a significant wing of American postliberalism overlaps with or descends directly from integralist arguments, even when it avoids the label. And that wing has acquired institutional weight. When Kevin Roberts, the newly appointed president of the Heritage Foundation, attended the 2021 National Conservatism conference and publicly aligned Heritage with the national conservative movement — reversing Heritage's own position from two years earlier — it signaled that this tendency had moved from academic journals to the commanding heights of American conservative institutions.

The diagnosis these thinkers offer is serious and deserves a serious answer. Liberal proceduralism, they argue, was never truly neutral. It embedded substantive commitments about autonomy, about the bracketing of transcendence from public life, about the priority of rights over duties — and then pretended those commitments were just the absence of commitments. The resulting society didn't stay neutral. It dissolved. Family breakdown, opioid deaths, pornography as a mass medium, institutional distrust at historic highs: integralists look at all of this and say liberalism did this, and patching liberalism won't fix it.

They're not entirely wrong about the problem. The problem is their solution. 

Their solution is a specific theological-political hierarchy: God, Church, State, Citizens. The state enforces moral order defined by the Church. Authority flows downward. Legitimacy is doctrinal. Correction, when it comes, comes from ecclesiastical hierarchy.

Any moral-political system needs an internal mechanism to recognize when its own principles are being used to justify persecution, scapegoating, or civic degradation — and that mechanism must function without relying on the goodwill of its current leaders. Call this the correction standard. It isn't a bar any particular system is guaranteed to clear. But any system that cannot clear it is not a moral order. It's an enforcement order waiting for the wrong enforcer.

I have pointed out that antisemitism is a metric to measure the morality of systems. Any political, moral or social system that allow antisemitism is not a moral system, by definition. The hatred of Jews or Judaism or the Jewish nation has been rationalized by sophisticated thinkers across centuries. It has attached itself to high-minded frameworks and emerged from them looking like a conclusion rather than a crime. 

That makes antisemitism uniquely diagnostic. A system that cannot identify why antisemitism is wrong at a structural level — not merely inconvenient, not merely regrettable, but a reasoning failure detectable from within the system's own principles — will also fail to identify other forms of systematic moral distortion. Antisemitism is the stress test precisely because it is so old, so elaborate, and so persistent. Pass it and your correction mechanism is real. Fail it and you've told us something important.

Integralism, unfortunately, fails it structurally.

Classic integralism places Catholic doctrinal authority at the apex of the political order. Jews are, by definition, outside that hierarchy. The best integralism has historically offered Jews is toleration as a subordinate category — the Augustinian "witness people" doctrine, permitted to exist in Christian society in permanently diminished civic status as living proof of the Old Testament's authenticity. That isn't protection from antisemitism. That is antisemitism, in theological dress.

The integralist regimes of the 19th and early 20th century didn't drift into antisemitism despite their principles. They expressed it through their principles. The framework contains no internal audit, no correction mechanism, no appeals process outside the hierarchy itself — which is to say, outside the historical source of the problem.

Modern integralists like Vermeule and Deneen don't espouse explicit antisemitism, and some actively disavow it. But good intentions are not a structural safeguard. Consider what has happened in the broader postliberal space. Candace Owens, who converted to Catholicism and has been warmly received in integralist-adjacent Catholic media, has made statements about Jews and Israel that are antisemitic by any rigorous definition. Tucker Carlson has platformed explicitly antisemitic voices, used demographic replacement rhetoric, and drifted toward treating Jewish institutional influence as a legitimate political grievance. 

Serious integralist thinkers would say these figures represent a hijacking — that they don't understand post-liberal ideas and shouldn't be held against them. But that response misidentifies the problem. The issue is not whether Owens and Carlson are integralist theorists. They aren't. The issue is that a movement explicitly claiming to restore moral order has shown no robust internal capacity to identify or repel antisemitic drift among adjacent allies — not when that drift serves broader anti-liberal goals, not when it's popular, not when calling it out is costly. That is not a hijacking problem; it is a correction mechanism problem. A framework that can be steered toward the oldest civilizational pathology in Western history, without its own principles generating an alarm, has told us everything we need to know about how it would function with state power behind it.

So where does that leave the right? It is philosophically exposed. 

The traditional conservative answer — call it fusionism — holds that free markets, limited government, and religious faith naturally reinforce each other, producing what its advocates called "ordered liberty": a society where people are free because their families, churches, and communities have formed them into people capable of governing themselves. It's an appealing vision. Yet integralists point to fifty years of family breakdown, addiction, and cultural dissolution and ask what exactly got ordered. The vision assumed its supporting institutions would remain healthy without political protection. They didn't.

A more sophisticated conservative answer draws on the political philosophy embedded in the American Founding — the idea that the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution already contain a moral order grounded in natural law, the self-evident truths that governments exist to protect rights inherent to human beings as such. This is more robust than simple fusionism because it doesn't depend on economic outcomes. But integralists mount a serious counterargument: the Founders' natural law was a product of Enlightenment rationalism, which is philosophically thinner than the centuries-deep tradition of Catholic moral theology going back to Aquinas. And the practical evidence is hard to dismiss — the Founders' framework has demonstrably failed to reproduce itself culturally across generations.

A third answer, Protestant nationalism, says integralism is a foreign import — that American Christianity is evangelical and biblical, not Catholic and hierarchical, and that restoring Christian moral culture doesn't require taking orders from Rome. This has real political force as a coalition argument. As a philosophical response to integralism it falls short, because it doesn't actually refute integralism's core challenge. It just asserts a different Christian preference.

None of these answer the question integralism is actually asking: where do the values that sustain a free society come from, and what do you do when they erode?

At this point, most people assume there are only two options: ground morality in God and religious authority (and fight out exactly which version of God and religion is the one people must follow), or accept the secular drift that integralists correctly diagnose as catastrophic. That is a false binary, and accepting it is what leaves the right philosophically defenseless.

The Enlightenment tried to derive morality from reason alone and produced frameworks too thin to sustain themselves culturally. But that failure doesn't mean the project is impossible. It means that particular attempt was insufficient. Rigorous moral reasoning doesn't require either divine authority at the top or secular relativism at the bottom. The assumption that it must produce one or the other is itself the error. There is a third path: moral reasoning that is transparent, auditable, pluralism-respecting, and capable of identifying its own failures — not because God commands it or because secular consensus endorses it, but because the reasoning holds and can be shown to hold.

What would that require? A framework in which authority comes from demonstrated coherence rather than institutional position. A correction mechanism that doesn't depend on the hierarchy being virtuous. A structure that accommodates genuine moral pluralism without collapsing into relativism. And — this is the test — a set of principles from which antisemitism can be identified as a reasoning failure, not merely a political liability.

That is the framework I am working on.

That framework doesn't yet have a prominent place in the debate on the right. It needs one. Because the alternative is a choice between liberal proceduralism that cannot defend itself and a theocratic politics that has already shown us, repeatedly, where it leads.

Any philosophy that cannot structurally guard against antisemitism is not merely incomplete. It is, by definition, an immoral philosophy — because it has no reliable way to distinguish moral order from moral catastrophe. That's not a Jewish complaint. That's a philosophical indictment. And it applies with full force to the most intellectually serious attempt the right has yet produced to answer the civilizational crisis it has correctly identified.


Tuesday, March 10, 2026

 


Something unusual is happening in Yemen. The Houthis — a movement whose official slogan includes "Death to America, Death to Israel, Damn the Jews" — are watching Iran take its heaviest blows in history and doing essentially nothing about it.

Why not?

At first I thought it was self-preservation. But Hezbollah, which has the same instinct, went all in, no doubt at Iran's behest. 

The Houthis are saying that they are waiting for the right moment. On March 9th, speaking during his Ramadan lectures, Abdul Malik al-Houthi explained, "Regarding military escalation and action, our fingers are on the trigger, ready to respond at any moment should developments warrant it."  

What is the right moment? For that, we need to understand a basic fact: for Iran, survival is victory. 

Iran's strategic objective right now is not to defeat the United States militarily. It is to survive the campaign with enough institutional continuity, territorial control, and proxy infrastructure to reconstitute its threat posture over time — and to create enough economic and political pressure on the coalition to force a ceasefire before that threat posture is fully dismantled.

The oil weapon is central to that strategy.

The Strait of Hormuz closure has removed approximately 20 million barrels per day from global markets,  roughly one-fifth of global oil consumption. There are partial mitigations available to make up some of this shortfall. Saudi Arabia's East-West Pipeline to Yanbu and the UAE's Habshan-Fujairah pipeline to the Gulf of Oman can together bypass the strait for perhaps 6-9 million bpd under optimal conditions, though drone strikes have already targeted Fujairah infrastructure and a Saudi oil field has been hit. Global spare production capacity outside the Gulf adds perhaps 1.5-3 million bpd. Strategic petroleum reserve draws from the U.S. and IEA members provide perhaps 2-4 million bpd of cushion measured in weeks, not months. U.S.-led naval escorts could restore another 0.5-2 million bpd through carefully batched convoys,  but commercial operators won't return at scale until the route is genuinely safe, not merely escorted, and insurers remain unwilling to write policies. Venezuela can only add about half a million bpd. 

Add all of it up generously, and the world can cover perhaps 10-14 million bpd of the shortfall. The remaining 6-10 million bpd, sustained over weeks and months, will do what oil shocks have always done: drive inflation, strain supply chains, and create political pressure on governments whose populations feel it at the pump. Asia absorbs over 80% of Hormuz oil flows. South Korea, Japan, and India are not parties to this conflict. Their governments will not remain silent indefinitely. And in the United States, Brent crude at $90-100 per barrel will eventually be measured in polling numbers.

This is Iran's path to survival: economic attrition with the world pressuring the US to end the war as soon as possible. 

Yet even the partial mitigation from the Saudi pipeline depends almost entirely on one assumption: that the Red Sea bypass route stays open.

The Houthis control the Bab-el-Mandeb strait at the southern entrance to the Red Sea. They have already demonstrated, over two years of operations, that they can make that corridor effectively impassable to commercial shipping through a sustained campaign of ballistic missiles, anti-ship cruise missiles, and one-way attack drones. During their previous campaign, the Houthis attacked 178 vessels, sinking four ships and killing nine sailors, forcing hundreds of commercial vessels to reroute around South Africa. 

Right now, ships going across the Red Sea to the Suez Canal are still unimpeded. The Saudi pipeline is safe for now. But the Houthis can make the entire Red Sea too dangerous for shipping; insurers would bail as soon as there is one ballistic missile aimed at the Yanbu port that the Saudis use. 

This is Iran's ace in the hole. Closing both the Straits of Hormuz and Bab-el-Mandeb, and harassing the ships already in the Red Sea, is an oil shock that the world cannot absorb now. 

If the Houthis enter now, they do so at the moment of maximum U.S. military attention and maximum carrier strike group presence. They would be struck hard, potentially decisively, while the political and military infrastructure to do so is fully in place. That is a bad trade, not just for the Houthis, but for Iran, which needs them intact for exactly the scenario described above.

The Houthis, kept intact and in reserve, are the instrument designed to execute the most important part of Iran's survival strategy at the critical moment.

The only question is timing. And here is where strategy must be considered more importantly than a literal interpretation of international law. Because there is no reason to wage the war in Iran's timetable. 

The Houthi threat should be addressed now, while the carriers are in place, while the military and political infrastructure to address it is mobilized. Waiting until they shoot their first missile or drone is exactly what Iran wants the US to do - because  Iran controls the timing to stay in power. 

Airstrikes against Houthi military infrastructure — launch sites, missile and drone storage, command and control — conducted now, as part of the broader campaign posture, carry a fraction of the political and operational cost they would carry in four or six weeks, when justifying renewed escalation becomes exponentially harder. The targeting intelligence accumulated during Operation Prosperity Guardian and the August 2025 strikes is there. The assets are in the region. The narrative logic — these are Iran's proxies, this is a single integrated threat network — is defensible and accurate.

The Houthis have already demonstrated their willingness to act against global shipping when Iran requests it. That is not a theoretical future threat — it is an established behavioral pattern with a two-year track record. The question is not whether they will do it, but when Iran decides the moment is optimal.

The Houthis are not acting out of self preservation. Like Hezbollah, they are doing exactly what their Iranian masters tell them to do. Iran needed Hezbollah to open up a second front to Israel at the outset of the war, but they need the Houthis to be wait and maintain their full capabilities. 

Waiting for that moment give Iran control of the most important single variable in the war's political sustainability: the oil price, and with it, the patience of every government in Asia and every voter in America watching their energy bills.

The Houthis are not standing down out of principle. They are being held in reserve as a weapon. The time to address a weapon is before it is fired, not after. 

We know they would use it on request. They already did.

Tuesday, March 3, 2026

 Sarojini Nadar’s Gender, Genocide, Gaza and the Book of Esther was released last year by Routledge. It takes a biblical story that begins with a legally sealed plan to exterminate every Jew in the Persian Empire and reframes it as a story about Jews wantonly killing Persians. 

The interpretive lens is declared from the outset: Gaza. The book assumes Israel is committing genocide. That assumption then becomes the key for rereading Esther. The ancient text is retrofitted to match the contemporary accusation.

The first paragraphs of the book make it obvious that Nadar is shoehorning Esther into her hate for Israel:


As we've noted many times, Netanyahu's invocation of Amalek was in terms of remembering what they did, not annihilating them - two separate commandments. 

The very premise of the book is false, based on a connection made by the author that has no basis in reality. 

The Book of Esther is centered around a royal decree to “destroy, kill, and annihilate” the Jews — men, women, and children — on a single appointed day. The decree is sealed. Persian law does not allow it to be revoked.

That is the existential core of the story.

But in this reading, the moral focus is relocated to the end — to the 75,000 enemies killed when the Jews defend themselves from the would-be genocidaires  That episode is elevated as the defining meaning of Esther. The extermination order against the Jews is a minor point barely mentioned.

In this book, Haman’s defining feature is not his genocidal antisemitism. It is his genealogy. He is an “Agagite,” linked to Amalek — a people once marked for destruction in earlier biblical texts. The Book of Esther definitely makes the link, but not in terms of destroying Amalek but in terms of the irrational hatred of the Jewish people that Amalek represents, both in the Torah and in Esther. 

Any Jewish schoolchild immediately associates Amalek with unmitigated evil. That is Esther's use of "Agagite."  His genocidal desire is based on one fact - that one Jew refuse to bow down to him, just as the Torah emphasizes that Amalek attacked the Israelites for no reason except hate, ambushing the Israelites from the rear where the weakest and slowest were trailing behind, when there was no threat. This is the paradigm of antisemitism. 

Instead of noting that obvious analogy between Haman and Amalek, Nadar creates a completely different analogy -one based on the idea that Jews are always the guilty ones. 

She even dismisses Haman's decree to murder every Jewish man, woman and child as  a "literary exaggeration."

But not Jews trying to survive. That is not exaggeration - that is "genocide." The violence against Haman and his allies is read not primarily as self-defense against extermination, but as Jews enacting a divine mandate to annihilate an ancient enemy. Haman the exterminator becomes Haman the theologically marked victim in her retelling.

The Book of Esther says repeatedly that the Jews struck “those who sought their harm.” It specifies that in Susa, 500 men were killed. It emphasizes three separate times that the Jews did not take plunder — despite being legally allowed to do so.

The narrative does not describe Jews slaughtering Persian civilians indiscriminately. It does not narrate women and children being killed by Jewish forces. It does not present expansion, conquest, or domination. In other words, by no definition can the Jews' self-defensive actions be called genocidal - unless that is how you look at Jews in general. 

Nadar denies any antisemitism. Yet her warped worldview prompts her to she even twist the Biblical account of Amalek itself to try to justify its actions as either self defense or pre-emptive defense of Canaan:


She's just "asking questions." Just like Holocaust deniers, just like Candace Owens. Instead of asking why people have hated Jews irrationally for the past 2,500 years, she asks what the Jews must have done to be hated. 

In Esther, Jews are no longer a threatened minority fighting to live. They are the eternal aggressors. In the Torah, the Israelites are not newly freed slaves who are being led to liberation but an aggressive threat to the presumably peaceful Amalekites. In Gaza, Israel is not a state responding to violence or existential threat. It is the inheritor of a biblical annihilation script.

In all cases, Jewish self-defense becomes morally illegitimate by definition. Any exercise of force, even in response to extermination, is reframed as genocidal intent. And antisemitism, uniquely among all types of hate,  is transformed into something that must be justified, somehow, because otherwise it doesn't make sense. 

Nadar does something similar in her thesis that the Book of Esther connects the sexual  subjugation of the king's harem with the Hebrew word herem, which can mean destruction. The words indeed are etymologically related, both denoting separation, but neither is used in Esther, yet Nadar uses this to connect the misogynistic behavior of a Persian king and the supposedly bloodthirsty Jews- she might as well connect Esther to the Arabic/Muslim word haram, forbidden, which also shares the same root word.

This book is moral inversion masquerading as scholarship. And it judges the Jews of Persia and even the Israelites through the same bigoted lens as it judges the Israeli Jews of today.

Sunday, March 1, 2026

 Harvard’s Carr-Ryan Center for Human Rights Policy is hosting an event this week titled From Apartheid to Democracy: A Blueprint for Peace in Israel-Palestine. The book it features proposes to “end apartheid and occupation rule” and establish a transitional framework leading to democratic decision-making about the territory’s future governance.

Universities should host controversial ideas. Human rights centers, especially, should not be timid. But intellectual seriousness requires clarity about what is being proposed — and what assumptions are being adopted.

The book's premise is that Israel is an apartheid state and that the area from the river to the sea is essentially a one state reality today. The problem isn't the book making these false claims; it is that the Carr Center is treating them as uncontested fact.

The Carr Center’s event description does not say “what the authors describe as apartheid.” It states, flatly, that the goal is to end apartheid and occupation rule. That framing is not neutral. Whether Israel constitutes an apartheid regime is one of the most fiercely debated legal and political claims in international discourse. I have demonstrated many times that the groups making those arguments twist international law for their own political purposes. Treating it as settled fact is itself a substantive position.

More importantly, the proposal being discussed is completely different than how human rights are discussed in the context of any other state. 

Normally, human rights groups either claim that a state is violating international law and demand it complies, or they seek to use existing legal frameworks to change the state's policies from the inside. Human rights advocacy typically demands compliance with international law within existing sovereign frameworks. It rarely proposes immediate regime replacement as the primary remedy.

Yet this is what is being suggested here. Only for Israel, a state that (whether the authors believe it or not) takes human rights and international law very seriously. 

According to the event description, the authors seek to design a transition government, reform laws and institutions, and lay the groundwork for democratic decision-making about the future governance of Israel-Palestine. In practice, that necessarily entails redefining sovereignty, citizenship, and political authority across the entire territory between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea.

Extending equal political rights across the entire territory prior to any final status decision would, as a matter of demographics and constitutional design, transform Israel’s identity as a Jewish-majority nation-state. That is not a marginal reform; it is a foundational restructuring of sovereignty. It would fundamentally alter Israel’s current national identity as a Jewish-majority nation-state. It is not honest to describe it as merely a technical peace plan. It is a proposal to replace the existing political order with a new one, without the approval of the current citizens of Israel, who would have no say on replacing their own government.

That is not democracy.

A human rights center has a special obligation here. Human rights law protects individual equality — but it also recognizes the right of peoples to self-determination. The tension between universal civic equality and national self-determination is one of the most difficult problems in modern political theory. Presenting a blueprint that effectively collapses one side of that tension without acknowledging it is not neutral scholarship.

The event description also frames the problem as Israel “waiting for a perfect partner for peace,” implying unilateral obstruction. It does not acknowledge Palestinian political fragmentation, the history of rejected proposals, Hamas’s continued control of Gaza, or the security collapse that followed Israel’s 2005 disengagement. One may dispute the weight of those factors, but omitting them entirely creates a moral asymmetry that undermines credibility. 

The fact that the Palestinians have rejected their own state, numerous times, since 1947, is ignored, and all those rejections are framed as Israel's fault alone. Yet Palestinian rejectionism was because they never wanted to build their own state where they can have rights, but to destroy another state. This plan fits in very well with that strategy,. It does not allow Jews to have rights, no matter what hand waving the authors claim. It is a warmed over version of Moammar Gaddafi's "Isratine" proposal.

There is another question the event framing does not confront: what prevents a transitional authority from descending into civil conflict? Regime replacement in deeply divided societies is historically volatile. South Africa is often invoked as a comparative case, but the Israeli-Palestinian conflict differs in demography, regional environment, armed non-state actors, and mutual existential fears. A glance at newspapers between 1945 and 1948 shows that Arabs were routinely attacking Jews and some Jewish groups responded in kind. People were murdered daily. That is the real "one state reality" that proponents of plans like this ignore.

If the event were structured as a debate, with explicit acknowledgment of competing interpretations of occupation, apartheid, and  the asymmetry of demanding the overhauls of the only Jewish state where Jews can practice self determination while not demanding the same for any other nation may exemplify academic rigor. 

As currently described, it reads like the Carr Center is accepting the false premises and the only debate is exactly how the Jewish state must be weakened or dismantled.

Beyond that, the book that is being discussed was written by and promoted by members of "Democracy for the Arab World Now."  DAWN  has treated Hamas primarily as a political actor rather than foregrounding its terrorism. A human rights organization that cannot bring itself to criticize Hamas is a peculiar one to be promoted by Harvard University. Beyonf that , DAWN has troubling ties to Islamist groups and its anti-Israel advocacy has no resemblance to fairness or accuracy. One example is its "doxxing" of members of AIPAC by putting their pictures on playing cards, reminiscent of armies who use playing cards so soldiers know who to target. DAWN knows the symbolism and chose to treat American Zionists as if they are war criminals deserving of being targeted for death. Why would the Carr Center even consider promoting a group that does such a thing?

A blueprint for peace is welcome. But clarity about what is being dismantled, what is being built, and whose rights are being recalibrated is not optional. It is the minimum standard for serious human rights scholarship.

As it stands, by accepting the premises of this book in its description, the Carr Center is abandoning the very human rights and democratic frameworks that they claim to uphold. 


EoZTV Podcast

Powered by Blogger.

follow me

search eoz

Recent posts from other blogs

subscribe via email

comments

Contact

translate

E-Book

source materials

reference sites

multimedia

source materials for Jewish learning

great places to give money

media watch

humor

.

Source materials

Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts Ever

follow me

Followers


pages

Random Posts

Pages - Menu

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون

Donate!

Tweets

Compliments

Monthly subscription:
Subscription options

One time donation:

Interesting Blogs

Categories

Best posts of 2016

Blog Archive

compliments

Algemeiner: "Fiercely intelligent and erudite"

Omri: "Elder is one of the best established and most respected members of the jblogosphere..."
Atheist Jew:"Elder of Ziyon probably had the greatest impression on me..."
Soccer Dad: "He undertakes the important task of making sure that his readers learn from history."
AbbaGav: "A truly exceptional blog..."
Judeopundit: "[A] venerable blog-pioneer and beloved patriarchal figure...his blog is indispensable."
Oleh Musings: "The most comprehensive Zionist blog I have seen."
Carl in Jerusalem: "...probably the most under-recognized blog in the JBlogsphere as far as I am concerned."
Aussie Dave: "King of the auto-translation."
The Israel Situation:The Elder manages to write so many great, investigative posts that I am often looking to him for important news on the PalArab (his term for Palestinian Arab) side of things."
Tikun Olam: "Either you are carelessly ignorant or a willful liar and distorter of the truth. Either way, it makes you one mean SOB."
Mondoweiss commenter: "For virulent pro-Zionism (and plain straightforward lies of course) there is nothing much to beat it."
Didi Remez: "Leading wingnut"