Donate Us

Help us keep this free site alive with a small contribution from you. Select an amount below.

Wednesday, April 29, 2026

Peter Beinart's latest piece in the New York Times makes the argument that right-wing anti-Zionism is genuinely antisemitic because it roots Israel's behavior in Jewish identity, while left-wing anti-Zionism is morally serious because it roots Israel's behavior in systems — colonialism, nationalism, and power. Tucker Carlson blames Israel's crimes on its Jewishness; progressives analyze structures. Therefore, Beinart suggests, the two are categorically different, and the progressive arguments are serious and fact-based.

The argument is superficially appealing, but it confuses vocabulary with logic. Both versions of anti-Zionism, right and left, turn out to depend on the same underlying premise: that Jews cannot be trusted to tell the truth — a conclusion the piece will earn, not assert.

The left's central accusations against Israel are claims about intent, not descriptions of behavior. Genocide requires the intent to destroy a people. Apartheid requires the intent to permanently dominate. Colonialism requires the intent to displace and replace. If your evidence for those accusations is based on reading minds, it is not evidence — unless there is no other credible explanation.

There is one, and it is more credible. The left's explanation — deliberate targeting, racial domination, eliminationist expansionism — requires attributing to Israel a set of intentions that Israel explicitly denies and that the historical and strategic evidence does not support. Israel's explanation fits the facts better: Israel is a Jewish state built by a people who internalized two thousand years of antisemitism as lived experience rather than historical abstraction, whose founding principle of Never Again functions as an operational imperative rather than an empty slogan, and whose moral framework derives from three thousand years of Jewish ethical thinking that the West itself largely inherited — and that the left applies selectively, inverting it against its source.

That last point matters more than it usually gets credit for. Israel is not a state indifferent to civilian casualties. It is a state whose entire military and legal culture is organized around minimizing them, because that is what its moral tradition demands. The IDF's doctrine of purity of arms, the military advocate general's office, the post-operation investigations, the evacuation warnings that forfeit tactical surprise — these are the institutional expression of a moral seriousness that runs through Jewish law on the conduct of war. And they are precisely why Hamas uses human shields. That strategy only works because Hamas correctly calculates that Israel will accept higher costs to its own soldiers rather than kill civilians indiscriminately. An army with genocidal intent does not generate that calculation in its enemies; it generates the opposite one.

What the left consistently refuses to recognize is that Israel is not choosing between war and peace. It is choosing between two moral costs: accept civilian casualties in Gaza while fighting an enemy that has made those casualties structurally unavoidable, or allow that enemy to terrorize Israeli civilians forever and with impunity. That is a genuine moral dilemma, the kind that three thousand years of Jewish ethical tradition was actually developed to navigate. The left's framework collapses it into a morality play with only one moral agent — Israel — and one set of lives that count. The moral cost of allowing Hamas to terrorize Israeli civilians indefinitely simply does not register as a cost. That omission is not an oversight; it is the premise.

This framing also resolves what the left's framework struggles to explain structurally. Israel is not a colonial project in any meaningful sense; it is the return of a people to their ancestral homeland, a homeland they never ceased to inhabit, mourn, or orient their prayers toward. It extends full citizenship to Arab Israelis, seats them on its Supreme Court, and elects them to its parliament, while maintaining Jewish survival as a founding priority — a priority that is entirely coherent given the history. And it allows thousands of trucks of aid into Gaza even while fighting there, because feeding civilians in a war zone is consistent with its own moral position. That last fact is almost never processed seriously by the left, because it is flatly inconsistent with the assumption of Israeli immorality that anchors their framework.

Which is where the epicycles begin. Arab judges on Israel's Supreme Court? Tokenism. LGBTQ rights? Pinkwashing — a deliberate propaganda strategy to distract from "apartheid." Evacuation warnings before strikes? Public relations. Aid convoys into Gaza? Cover for genocide. Nothing counts against the theory; everything gets absorbed into it, reclassified as deception, filed under further evidence that the malice runs deeper than it appears.

The pro-Israel explanation is consistent with the facts as they present themselves. The left's explanation is coherent only by reclassifying every inconvenient fact as performance. One framework has to keep adding mind-reading and assumptions of deception to survive contact with reality. The other doesn't. Which means there is no structural difference between the progressive position and a conspiracy theory.

I've written before about the difference between correspondence and coherence theories of truth, and how conspiracy theories are epistemologically indistinguishable from the coherence model. In a correspondence framework, claims are tested against reality, and evidence can falsify them. In a coherence framework, claims are judged by how well they fit the narrative, and contradictions are reinterpreted until the system stays intact. Conspiracy theories survive exactly this way: counterevidence doesn't weaken the theory, it proves how deep the conspiracy goes.

The contemporary left critique of Israel has adopted that structure. Israel isn't liberal — it's pretending to be. Its institutions aren't genuine — they're performative. Its justifications aren't honest — they're propaganda. The particular content of the accusation varies, but the underlying move is the same: nothing Israel or its supporters say or demonstrate can be taken at face value, because the deception is total. Which is exactly how antisemites have looked at Jews for centuries — deceptive, cunning, conspiratorial, pursuing a hidden agenda of power over non-Jews.

Beinart argues that the left avoids essentializing Jews because it speaks the language of systems rather than identity. But the left's systemic framework only remains coherent if it assumes, as a standing premise, that Jewish institutions are uniquely deceptive — that their visible behavior is systematically misleading and their explanations are not to be accepted at face value the way Hamas's claims are. Without that premise, the coherent narrative collapses, because counterevidence would have to be taken seriously and the theory would have to update.

Which brings us back to Tucker Carlson, whose theories Beinart correctly identifies as antisemitic conspiracy thinking. Carlson speaks openly about Jewish civilizational threat and hidden manipulation. The mechanism is recognizable: start with a fixed conclusion, interpret all evidence through that lens, reclassify contradiction as proof of how cunning the deception is.

Strip away the vocabulary, and the left's framework runs on the same engine. The right says Jews are dangerous because they intend to control the world; the left says Israel is dangerous because of its predetermined intentions to dominate its Arab neighbors and population. Both use the same logic and the same assumptions of Jewish evil. Only one of them is honest enough to say "Jews."

Beinart wants to draw a moral boundary, and there is one — only it falls in a different place than he draws it. The dividing line runs between those willing to test their claims against reality and those who build arguments that reality is not permitted to challenge. Cross that line and it no longer matters how sophisticated your language is or how carefully you avoid biological essentialism.

Beinart writes that "combating the anti-Israel right's conflation of Israel and Jewishness is made harder by pro-Israel American Jewish organizations that have conflated those two things as well." Yet Beinart's own argument depends on antisemitic tropes no less than Carlson's does — the assumption of Israeli Jewish intent to dominate and destroy, which is the complete opposite of how Jews and Israel understand themselves and their history. His framework requires that premise to function. Whether he sees it or not, he is in the same epistemic territory as Tucker Carlson, and his column's purpose — to persuade readers that he isn't — is the most clarifying thing about it.

Sunday, April 26, 2026

Last night, a man named Cole Allen walked up to a security checkpoint outside the White House Correspondents' Dinner armed with a shotgun, a handgun, and multiple knives. He told investigators he wanted to shoot Trump administration officials. A Secret Service agent was struck by a round; his vest saved his life. President Trump was rushed off the stage. It was the third attempt on a sitting or former president in two years.

Within minutes of the news breaking, Hasan Piker — whose initial reaction to the shooting was to joke about a conspiracy, implying press secretary Karoline Leavitt had foreknowledge because she had earlier said Trump would "bring the heat" and "shots will be fired" at the dinner — was doing what he does: performing for the crowd that has made him one of the most influential political voices in America.

Piker himself last year had endorsed the meme of "someone needs to do it" as a widely understood dog whistle to assassinate Trump.

Keep in mind that Piker is now considered mainstream.  He campaigns at rallies for Democratic candidates including Zohran Mamdani, Bernie Sanders, Summer Lee, and Abdul El-Sayed. The Harris campaign invited him to livestream from the 2024 Democratic National Convention. The New York Times has given him a flattering profile, a podcast appearance, and an op-ed. Ezra Klein's column originally ran under the headline "Hasan Piker Is Not the Enemy," changed after ridicule made the title untenable, though the defense of Piker within it was not changed.

So what exactly has the Times been platforming? Piker called for Sen. Rick Scott to be killed during a live stream: "If you cared about Medicare fraud or Medicaid fraud, you would kill Rick Scott." He is famous for arguing that America "deserved 9/11." When the New York Times podcast asked him about the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, he never once suggested it was wrong to assassinate people or acknowledged the immorality of extrajudicial murder — instead immediately invoking Friedrich Engels's concept of "social murder" to justify the killing. He has told followers to "kill" and "murder" people "in the streets" and "let the streets soak in their red-capitalist blood." Piker  insists Hamas is "a thousand times better" than Israel and has described Hezbollah's banner as his favorite flag. On October 7, he said: "It doesn't matter if rape happened on October 7th. It doesn't change the dynamic for me."

This is the person the New York Times treats as a legitimate political voice worth treating with respect.




Now: is any of this illegal? Perhaps some of it — the First Amendment does not protect true threats or direct incitement to imminent lawless action, and there is a reasonable legal argument that some of Piker's statements approach that line. The Supreme Court's Brandenburg test requires that speech be directed to inciting imminent lawless action and likely to produce it. "You would kill Rick Scott" is closer to that line than most of Piker's defenders admit, and "let the streets soak in their red-capitalist blood" is closer still. But the legal question is genuinely uncertain, and legal scholars will argue about it.

The moral question is not uncertain at all.

There is a category error so common in contemporary American life that it has become invisible: the conflation of legality with morality. If something is legal, the argument goes, then objecting to it on moral grounds is at best squeamishness and at worst an assault on free speech. But legality and morality operate at entirely different levels. The law is a floor — the minimum standard of behavior a society can compel with the threat of force. Morality is the ceiling, or rather the open sky above it: the vast domain of behavior that the law was never designed to reach and cannot reach without becoming something far worse than what it is trying to prevent.

The First Amendment is a legal floor. It means the government cannot imprison Hasan Piker for his statements. It says nothing whatsoever about whether those statements are acceptable, whether platforms should carry them without consequence, whether media institutions should legitimize them with the imprimatur of prestigious bylines, whether sponsors should finance the audiences they cultivate, or whether political candidates should campaign alongside someone who has openly cheered political violence and the rape of Israeli women. The First Amendment protects Piker's right to speak. The rest of us retain our right — and bear our obligation — to respond.

The mechanism for that response is what the critics of political violence have always had available: social pressure, institutional accountability, and the withdrawal of legitimacy. Boycott sponsors. Refuse to appear alongside him on panels and stages. Decline to grant him the credibility that comes from being treated as a normal participant in civic debate. 

When The New York Times platforms him, it is engaged in immorality. When Democratic candidates campaign with him, they are making a conscious choice to promote immorality. When companies advertise on his show they are directly condoning his immorality.  To push back on all of these actions, both socially and financially,  would not be acts of censorship but of moral seriousness.

The book I am completing on America at 250 makes this point at length in a different context. America gives us rights but it also gives us obligations to be good citizens. We owe things to our families, our communities, and our nation. It is patriotic to oppose restrictions on free speech but it is also patriotic to oppose speech that erodes the quality of American life. And that is exactly what calls for violence, whether it is a coded message to assassinate the President or cheering the murder of a health care executive or threatening to use "any means possible" including violence to silence the speech of others. 

This is part of the covenant between the people of the United States. A nation where political violence is normalized cannot stand. This cannot be done by law; it can only be done by citizens, institutions, and cultural gatekeepers who understand that the legal floor is the beginning of the moral conversation, not the end of it.

The America that produced the First Amendment also produced the expectation that it would be used responsibly — that the freedom to speak carried with it the social obligation to speak in ways that did not incite neighbors against each other. That expectation was enforced not by courts but by culture: by editors who declined to publish certain things, by audiences who withdrew patronage from those who cheered violence, by communities that applied social consequences to people whose speech fell beneath a moral threshold that the law did not reach. That culture has not disappeared, but it has been systematically weakened by a generation that learned to treat the legal floor as the only relevant standard.

What happened last night at the Washington Hilton did not occur in a vacuum. Cole Allen did not emerge from nowhere. He emerged from an information environment in which a man with millions of followers can spend years normalizing violence against political targets, calling for senators to be killed, excusing the murder of executives, laughing at the rape of Israeli women, and then be invited to the Democratic National Convention, given a podcast slot by the New York Times, and welcomed as a surrogate by candidates running for the United States Senate. Maybe people like Piker manage to stay just barely on the side of legality, but how the rest of us respond to someone like that is the real test of what it means to be an American.

The First Amendment will survive Hasan Piker just fine. The question is whether American civic culture will — and the answer depends not on judges but on whether the rest of us remember that the floor is where behavior is compelled and the ceiling is where character, including the character of America itself, is revealed.

Friday, April 17, 2026

 UNIFIL has reported over 10,000 Israeli violations of Resolution 1701 since the November 2024 ceasefire. This number (or larger ones) are widely quoted as evidence of Israel not adhering to agreements.

How many Hezbollah violations has UNIFIL reported in the same period? 

Here is where things get interesting. 

The Israeli number is precise, cumulative, and built for headlines. UNIFIL's spokesperson delivered it to wire services around the one-year ceasefire mark: over 8,100 air violations, over 2,600 ground activities north of the Blue Line, over 1,000 firing trajectories. 

The Hezbollah-side number appears nowhere in a comparable form. It was not mentioned in the same press conference. 

The Secretary-General's periodic 1701 reports to the Security Council do classify Hezbollah-linked weapons south of the Litani as violations — the language is explicit. The reports provide counts: 194 caches discovered in one period, 225 by another, over 360 by late 2025. So it sounds like UNIFIL is impartially reporting violations to the UN.

That is not close to true when you look at what they consider to be a single "violation."

For Israel, a sortie gets counted by individual plane, not as a single event. Most of the violations were not Israeli jets but drones - yet a single drone flight over Lebanon can count as multiple violations. A drone loitering for hours, changing direction or altitude, gets broken into distinct trajectories — each one a separate entry in the ledger. One reconnaissance mission back and forth along the Blue Line can produce five or ten violations by itself.

Now compare how UNIFIL reports the weapons caches it finds out about. Every cache is counted once, whether it contains three old rifles or a thousand rockets. A shoebox of corroded AK magazines and a tunnel stocked with Kornet anti-tank missiles are both "one cache." 

Israeli violations are counted in the smallest possible units. Hezbollah violations are counted in the largest possible aggregates.

It gets worse. UNIFIL is only counting what it knows about directly or through the LAF. Yet Hezbollah freely brags that it misleads the Lebanese authorities by leaking outdated caches for them to blow up, keeping the real, active underground warehouses and the caches hidden in civilian houses along the border untouched. The commander who told NPR "we gave them empty boxes, or a few old items to go blow up" was describing exactly the material that fills UNIFIL's 360+ cache count. The one metric UNIFIL reports for Hezbollah compliance is the metric Hezbollah openly games.

100 violations in a single school
If UNIFIL counted Hezbollah violations the same way it counts Israeli violations, then every rifle, every grenade, every RPG, every rocket, every mortar round, every launcher, every IED, every Kornet would count as a separate violation of 1701 — because each one is. Hezbollah's pre-war arsenal south of the Litani was assessed in open sources at tens of thousands of rockets, thousands of anti-tank missiles, tens of thousands of RPGs and small arms, plus substantial quantities of mortars, grenades, and IEDs. The IDF has already seized over 85,000 weapons and military items from a partial sweep of roughly 30 villages. Combat Engineering Battalion 603A was reported  to have found and destroyed over 1,000 terror infrastructure sites, with "endless" weapons in only five weeks of operations.  Conservative totals of individual weapons south of the Litani — each one a 1701 violation — run well into the hundreds of thousands. If you count individual munitions and bullets, into the millions. Which is no more outrageous than counting a single drone patrolling the Blue Line as ten violations, as UNIFIL does.

And weapons are only half of it. Resolution 1701 prohibits "any armed personnel, assets or weapons" other than the LAF and UNIFIL in the area. Every armed Hezbollah fighter south of the Litani is a standalone violation, independent of what he is carrying. The Radwan Force alone was assessed at several thousand fighters forward-deployed in the south before the war, with total Hezbollah armed personnel in the area running considerably higher. Those are thousands more violations UNIFIL has never counted.

You will not find any press conference where UNIFIL says Hezbollah has violated 1701 hundreds of thousands of times.

UNIFIL cooks the books. It maximizes the count of Israeli violations and minimizes the count of Hezbollah violations, both in number and in kind. This is before accounting for its long documented history of turning a blind eye to what Hezbollah was actually building in southern Lebanon — eighteen years during which Hezbollah constructed an arsenal of tens of thousands of rockets and missiles, tunnels rivaling Gaza's, and Radwan Force infrastructure within meters of UNIFIL positions, and UNIFIL filed almost nothing. 

The post-ceasefire counting is not a departure from that record. It is its continuation by arithmetic.

The 10,000 figure circulating in the world's media is not evidence of Israeli misconduct. It is evidence of UNIFIL's bias - and uselessness.

Sunday, April 12, 2026

 


Brussels Signal reports:

France’s foreign ministry has said the European Union’s association agreement with Israel could be reopened for discussion in light of what it calls “disproportionate” Israeli strikes on Lebanon.

Speaking today, Pascal Confavreux, spokesperson for the ministry, stated that given the gravity of yesterday’s events in Lebanon and the situation in the West Bank: “One cannot exclude that the discussion on the suspension of the EU-Israel association agreement will reopen, in addition to national sanctions.”

He added that while Israel has the right to defend itself, its actions are “not only unacceptable but also disproportionate and lead de facto to an impasse”. 
The word "disproportionate" has a specific legal meaning. 
The IHL formulation of the rule of proportionality requires a balancing of the foreseeable civilian harm and the expected military advantage based on the knowledge available to the military commander at the time prior to the initiation of an attack. 
To determine if an attack is disproportionate, one must know what the military value of the attack is and balance it against civilian harm. 

France has no idea what Israel's targets were. So it cannot possibly know whether the attacks were disproportionate. Using that language in this context is wrong.

Now, a few days after the attack, what do we know?

Lebanese officials claim tat over 300 people were killed. Israel claims that it killed 180 Hezbollah fighters and also aimed at other Hezbollah military assets.

A 3:2 ratio of militants to civilians, in an urban area, would never be considered disproportionate when done by any other army. In history. 

Israel is not saying that there were any mistakes. It confirms the airstrikes - most done in a single ten minute period over wide parts of Lebanon. The IDF has lots of lawyers who look at the legality of every individual strike before it happens. In other words, the IDF knew what its targets were, what the likely civilian casualties would be, and decided that the military advantage outweighed the expected civilian losses under international law, knowing all those facts.

France knows none of this.

Words matter. Assuming Israel's tally of terrorists killed in accurate, France's use of the term "disproportionate" is objectively wrong. And even without that tally, France is irresponsible for using that term without knowing the intended targets and their military value.

EoZTV Podcast

Powered by Blogger.

follow me

search eoz

Recent posts from other blogs

subscribe via email

comments

Contact

translate

E-Book

source materials

reference sites

multimedia

source materials for Jewish learning

great places to give money

media watch

humor

.

Source materials

Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts Ever

follow me

Followers


pages

Random Posts

Pages - Menu

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون

Donate!

Tweets

Compliments

Monthly subscription:
Subscription options

One time donation:

Interesting Blogs

Categories

Best posts of 2016

Blog Archive

compliments

Algemeiner: "Fiercely intelligent and erudite"

Omri: "Elder is one of the best established and most respected members of the jblogosphere..."
Atheist Jew:"Elder of Ziyon probably had the greatest impression on me..."
Soccer Dad: "He undertakes the important task of making sure that his readers learn from history."
AbbaGav: "A truly exceptional blog..."
Judeopundit: "[A] venerable blog-pioneer and beloved patriarchal figure...his blog is indispensable."
Oleh Musings: "The most comprehensive Zionist blog I have seen."
Carl in Jerusalem: "...probably the most under-recognized blog in the JBlogsphere as far as I am concerned."
Aussie Dave: "King of the auto-translation."
The Israel Situation:The Elder manages to write so many great, investigative posts that I am often looking to him for important news on the PalArab (his term for Palestinian Arab) side of things."
Tikun Olam: "Either you are carelessly ignorant or a willful liar and distorter of the truth. Either way, it makes you one mean SOB."
Mondoweiss commenter: "For virulent pro-Zionism (and plain straightforward lies of course) there is nothing much to beat it."
Didi Remez: "Leading wingnut"