Donate Us

Help us keep this free site alive with a small contribution from you. Select an amount below.

Monday, October 13, 2025

There are too many moving parts, too many secrets and too little solid information around the current hostage release and US-brokered/pressured ceasefire to know whether it is a victory or not.[30][31] But we can look at the past two years and see a change in Israel's defense posture and military strategy that definitely helped revolutionize the entire region for the better.[0][1]

Before 2023, Israel's military strategy was always against those who directly attacked it - whether Hamas, West Bank militant groups or Hezbollah.[5] It was no secret that these groups were supported by Iran, Qatar and Turkey but Israel was most reluctant to go after their sponsors because of fears of escalation and international pressure.[5][7]

After October 7, Israel's posture changed to the realization that the octopus' tentacles will always grow back no matter how many times they are severed.[3] And, crucially, its fear of condemnation by the world went to zero.[3]

It may even be that the slanderous and utterly false charges of "genocide" hurled at Israel in the immediate months after October 7 helped crystallize this strategy, since once the world already accuses you of the worst possible crime, what downside is there to escalate to attack the financial, political and military source of the threat?[3]

Israel's blows against Hezbollah and Iran, both the spectacular attacks on highly visible targets as well as the non-stop lower-level attacks on Iran's supply chain to Hezbollah across Syria, can be seen a year later as being key to the severe degradation of Hezbollah's military and political fortunes.[40][41][42][44] The very acts that prompted the most extreme anti-Israel rhetoric were the ones that contributed most towards a more peaceful Middle East by largely sidelining and silencing Iran.[48] Lebanon is no longer living in fear of Hezbollah, Syria's leader has fallen and (for all the many caveats on its new leadership) Syria has turned into a potential partner for peace.[20][22][23][26]

But while Iran supports Hamas, its real oxygen comes through Doha and Istanbul.[4][10] And Israel's seemingly failed attempt to assassinate Hamas leaders in Qatar changed the entire calculus of the region.[11][12][15]

Even though it seemed at the time to be a major failure and indeed embarrassment, Israel's strike at a Hamas meeting in Doha sent a signal to Hamas' sponsors that if they continue to support the terror group, there is nothing - not even Donald Trump - that restrains Israel's desire to stop them.[10][15][18]

This message didn't only reverberate in Qatar but in Turkey as well.[4][10] Instantly, Hamas went from an asset that can be used to leverage popular support into a major liability.[10]

Trump recognized this and saw an opportunity to use this new chess board to his advantage.[18] But in the end, Israel's goals for the war - saving the hostages, ending Hamas' rule in Gaza - never wavered.[8] While it is too soon to know for sure, it appears that everyone in the region is finally agreeing with those goals and willing to pressure Hamas to end its rule over Gaza.[32][38]

The deal is far from perfect, and the devil is in the details of what Hamas' future will be and whether it will be energized by the release of its worst terrorists.[32][34][35] Remember that Yahya Sinwar was released from Israeli prisons in the Shalit deal.[34]

But it was Israeli strength, tactical brilliance, unparalleled intelligence, unwavering goals and willingness to go after those who gave Hamas oxygen that led to this day.[1][2] Israel's regional neighbors received this message loud and clear.[0] Israel's political fortunes can only go up from here, and it has regained the respect and fear of the entire Middle East, which is a prerequisite for any sort of lasting peace.[1][2]

References

  1. Brookings: Israel's Post-October 7 Strategy and Regional Implications
  2. CSIS: Israel's Tactical Shift Against the Axis of Resistance
  3. FDD: Regaining Deterrence for Middle East Peace
  4. Haaretz: From Restraint to Reach: Israel's Bold New Doctrine
  5. Al Jazeera: Turkey, Qatar View Hamas as Liability Post-Doha Strike
  6. Israel Hayom: Pre-October 7: Limits of Israeli Strategy
  7. Jerusalem Post: Fears of Escalation Kept Israel in Check
  8. Times of Israel: Netanyahu Outlines Unwavering Gaza War Goals
  9. Reuters: Qatar Strike Shifts Hamas Dynamics in Sponsors
  10. BBC: Israel's Doha Strike: Failure or Turning Point?
  11. NYT: How Israel's Qatar Strike Reshaped Regional Calculus
  12. Washington Post: The Message from Doha's Strike to Hamas Backers
  13. Politico: Trump Leverages Israel Strike for Ceasefire Win
  14. Le Monde: Lebanon Freed from Hezbollah's Shadow
  15. Guardian: Syria After Assad: Pathways to Peace
  16. Economist: Syria's New Dawn Amid Caveats
  17. Foreign Affairs: Post-Assad Syria as Peace Partner
  18. CNN: Gaza Ceasefire: Too Many Secrets to Call Victory
  19. AP: Uncertainties in US-Brokered Gaza Deal
  20. Haaretz: Regional Consensus to End Hamas Rule
  21. JPost: Risks of Prisoner Releases Like Sinwar in Shalit Deal
  22. Times of Israel: Gaza Deal: Devil in Hamas Future Details
  23. Al-Monitor: Arab Pressure for Hamas Gaza Exit
  24. ISW: Hezbollah's Degradation from Israeli Strikes
  25. RAND: Impact of Israeli Strikes on Hezbollah Supply Chain
  26. CNAS: Syria Strikes and Iran Proxy Degradation
  27. Atlantic Council: Hezbollah's Post-Strike Fortunes
  28. Foreign Policy: Sidelining Iran for Mideast Peace

Thursday, September 25, 2025

 We see a familiar pattern with most public instances of bigotry.  A racist incident hits the news, and the public response – at least in open, mainstream circles – is usually horror and shame. People distance themselves from the racism, organizations reaffirm their opposition to it, there is outrage in the media and social media, perhaps prompting some protests, and prejudice is pushed a little further back underground.

Antisemitism, though, behaves differently. When antisemitic incidents occur – whether disguised as “anti-Zionism” or brazenly explicit – they often don’t generate horror. Instead, they seem to embolden others. What should be a cautionary tale becomes a rallying cry. 

Antisemitism strengthens on its own exposure.

It is a kind of stigmatization rebound effect.

There are studies that explain parts of this phenomenon:

  • Prejudice rebound in psychology. Social psychologists have long documented that when people try to suppress their biases, the thoughts can come back stronger. Monteith and others called this the stereotype rebound effect: the act of pushing prejudice out of sight primes it to resurface later with greater intensity.

  • Reactance against stigma. Stigma campaigns can backfire when people perceive them as policing thought or speech. Studies of stigma reduction show that those told “you must not think this way” sometimes double down out of reactance【turn0search10†source】.

  • Secondary antisemitism. German social psychologists Daniel Imhoff and Rainer Banse ran experiments showing that reminders of Jewish victimhood actually increased antisemitism in some respondents, once social-desirability filters were removed. They called this secondary antisemitism – hostility that grows stronger the more one is confronted with the suffering of Jews.

  • Permission structures. Surveys and testimonies show that many Jews perceive the rise of antisemitism not as the creation of new hatreds but as the release of old ones. A 2020 Pew study found Jews saying, in essence: “It’s not that people became antisemitic; it’s that they now feel freer to say it”. Dara Horn recently described this as a “permission structure” for antisemitism in The Atlantic.

Put together, these lines of research help explain why antisemitic incidents don’t reduce antisemitism. They activate latent prejudice, provoke reactance against stigma, and signal permission to express what was already there. This is unique compared to other prejudices:

Antisemitism is widespread but under-measured, since most surveys rely on self-reporting. People know the “correct” answers so it is difficult to measure how many people have latent antisemitic feelings. I've mentioned one study that found it indirectly; and the German study above managed to get people to admit antisemitic opinions when they were told that they were hooked up to a reliable lie detector. The people with latent antisemitic attitudes are the ones who are more likely to look at antisemitic incidents not as something horrific but as evidence that they are not alone. The antisemites may even be admired as "speaking truth to power."

One other reason that antisemitic incidents don't provoke the same reaction as violent incidents against minorities, women or the disabled is because Jews are not hated for their weakness but for their perceived power. The idea of the powerful getting knocked down a peg is a mainstream meme in entertainment and media.

The result is a self-reinforcing loop. Antisemitism doesn’t wither under the light of day; it metastasizes.

The scholarship gives us pieces – prejudice rebound, reactance, secondary antisemitism, permission structures. But none quite capture the full picture.

That’s why stigmatization rebound is a useful frame. It names the paradox: incidents that should stigmatize hatred instead rebound, drawing out and intensifying the very prejudice they should suppress.

Recognizing this dynamic matters because it exposes why antisemitism cannot be fought with the same tools used against racism or other prejudices. Public shaming, exposure, and education alone don’t work the same way. With antisemitism, exposure often legitimizes and emboldens. Holocaust education, often seen as the only tool in the fight, can backfire. 

This is why it is so maddening when people claim that existing anti-discrimination education is adequate to deal with antisemitism. It is not only inadequate - it is entirely wrong, and its themes of aa binary oppressor/oppressed dynamic often exacerbate rather than ameliorate antisemitism.

That doesn’t mean we stop fighting. It means we need new strategies that acknowledge how antisemitism feeds on its own visibility, and how easily anti-Zionism provides moral cover for what is, at its core, an ancient hatred looking for new clothes.

I think that the key tool to fight antisemitism is to attack the malign philosophies that encourage it - ideas like decolonial studies, Marxism and social justice. They claim that they are anti-discrimination but they are, in fact, one root of the problem. 

There may be other methods and tools that can fight the scourge. But at the moment, I have not seen too many good ideas from the many strategy papers I have read..


Monday, September 8, 2025

 British Leftists are now far more likely to admit to classic antisemitic attitudes than those on the Right, according to a new YouGov poll.


There used to be an interesting anomaly in polling about antisemitism. Since Leftists regard themselves as being against all forms of bigotry, it was much harder to get them to answer questions that were clearly meant to measure blatant antisemitic attitudes because they wouldn't want to admit bigotry. One poll from 2021 managed to figure out how to measure double standards against Jews and found that antisemitism was correlated with higher education levels - the exact opposite of the conventional wisdom.

This new poll shows that the reluctance of the Left to express classic antisemitic attitudes is disappearing. They are now more willing to openly endorse classic antisemitic stereotypes.

Researchers used these six questions as indicators of classic antisemitic attitudes, three framed positively and three negatively:
Can Jews be trusted just as much as other British people in business?

Are Jews just as loyal to Britain as other British people?

Are you just as open to having Jewish friends as you are to having friends from other sections of British society?

Compared to other groups, do Jews have too much power in the media?

Do Jews talk about the Holocaust just to further their political agenda?

Do Jews chase money more than other people do?
There are also six questions about Israel, but for determining antisemitism, these questions were the guide.

21% of people in Britain answered the antisemitic way on at least four of these questions, double the number in 2021.

But the political leanings of the antisemites is really the story here:

The only two political groups that exceeded the 21% general adult antisemitic numbers were voters for  the Green Party (44%) and Labour (25%.)

When you factor in that many leftist antisemites still would not want to be considered antisemitic, chances are the real numbers are even worse!

Yes, right-wing antisemitism is a real problem - no one denies it. Bu tright-wing antisemitism in Britain tends to be fringe and extremist, while Left-wing antisemitism is seeping into the mainstream, reshaping political culture itself.

Other findings:
Among Green Party voters, 15 per cent believe that the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct 7 2023 was justified, higher than any other major party’s voters. 
29 per cent of Labour voters believe that Israel can get away with anything because its supporters control the media.

This is proof positive that anti-Zionism and antisemitism are two sides of the same coin. For years, the Left has been insisting that they aren't antisemitic at all - but this poll proves otherwise.  

The threat to Jews in England comes from the Left more than from the Right.

Sunday, August 31, 2025

 



In July 2023, the journal Frontiers in Public Health published a paper by Bram Wispelwey, Osama Tanous, Yara Asi, Weeam Hammoudeh and David Mills titled "Because its power remains naturalized: introducing the settler colonial determinants of health."

They claim that in Israel and elsewhere, the "colonized" have poorer health because of the supposed "settler colonialism" they suffer under.

This is not the only study that blames poorer Arab health compared to Jews in the region on nebulous factors like racism or colonialism. A series of recent papers (many of whom share some of the same authors) have been pushing this narrative: 
Smith J, Kwong EJL, Hanbali L, Hafez S, Neilson A, Khoury R. Violence in Palestine demands immediate resolution of its settler colonial root causes. BMJ Glob Health 2023;8:e014269. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2023-014269.

Tanous O. On settler colonialism, environment, and health. Jerusalem Quarterly 2023;95:112–15.

Asi YM, Hammoudeh W, Mills D, Tanous O, Wispelwey B. Reassembling the pieces: settler colonialism and the reconception of Palestinian health. Health Hum Rights 2022;24:229–35. PMID: PMC9790940.

Asi YM, Sharif MZ, Wispelwey B, Abuelezam NN, Ahmed AK, Samari G. Racism as a threat to Palestinian health equity. Health Equity 2024;8:371–5. https://doi.org/10.1089/heq.2024.0027.

It does not take long to not only debunk this theory, but to advance an alternative theory that is much stronger to explain why Arab Israelis and Palestinian Arabs have a lower life expectancy than Israeli Jews. 

Let's ignore the fact that Israel is not a settler-colonialist state, since Jews are indigenous to the region. 

If settler colonial determinants of health (SCDH) were real, then one would expect that Arabs under Israeli rule or "occupation" have worse health than their neighbors in Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt and Syria, who do not live under such circumstances. 

Yet the life expectancy of Palestinian and Israeli Arabs is 76, while their neighbors average about 74.5.



That is a negative correlation.

Yet Israeli Arabs do have lower life expectancy than Israeli Jews, which is 83 years. That is certainly a significant difference. If "settler colonialism" is not the major reason, what is?

Modern medicine loves to look at social factors as underlying health determinants - things like poverty or marginalization. Of course, "poverty" does not cause health problems any more than "settler colonialism" does - the use of the word "determinants" in SCDH is knowingly deceptive. There may be correlations, but nothing about poverty causes poor health - it is at best a second-order factor, because perhaps poverty indicates less access to health facilities, or more stress. But social factors, by themselves, are never determinants. 

Let's look at poverty. There is no doubt that Arab Israelis have lower incomes and higher poverty rates than Israeli Jews do, so a superficial glance at only those two factors would seem to indicate some correlation.

However, there is another well-defined group in Israeli society that has high poverty rates: religious Haredi Jews. And if you look at their life expectancy you can see that it is higher than that of non-Haredi Jews in Israel!  The Haredi population has a life expectancy of 84.5 years, a full year and a half over other Israeli Jews. 

So what accounts for these seemingly contradictory results? If it isn't settler colonialism, and it isn't poverty, then what is it that is the major factor for determining life expectancy?

If you had to choose one dominant health factor, the answer is simple: smoking.




If you compare life expectancy with smoking rates, among Haredi, non-Haredi Jewish Israeli , Israeli Arab and Palestinian men and women, the negative correlation between smoking and life expectancy is a very high -0.934.

This is a much stronger correlation than other first-order health factors like obesity or diabetes. 

When academic health papers are biased like these,  and ignore easily obtained statistics and methodologies that undermine their theories, that is no longer just bias or antisemitism. It is a threat to the entire health industry. Public health must be guided by evidence, not activism. When empirically measurable factors like smoking rates show a near-perfect inverse correlation with life expectancy, ignoring them in favor of untestable theories is not only unscientific - it's unethical.

This is not the only problem with the SCDH theory. But it is enough to show that within some health circles, activism is trumping science. That should concern everyone, no matter what your position is on Israel. 

One shudders to think that these health professionals are spending more effort to slander Israel in the name of Arab health than to promote anti-smoking initiatives among Palestinians and Arab Israelis - an idea that Israeli health officials would gladly embrace.

(h/t Andrew P)


Wednesday, July 23, 2025

 The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation sent a letter to the UN offering to provide security for the delivery of aid that is rotting away inside Gaza.


UN agencies continue to assert that a lack of permissions and security is impeding aid delivery. However, the reality on the ground tells a different story. More than 400 aid distribution points run by the UN and its partners remain closed. Kitchens have shuttered, trucks sit idle, drivers are striking, and convoys are routinely looted. This is not an access issue. It is a capacity and operational issue, and the world deserves honesty about that distinction. 

We are aware that the UN and other aid organizations have essential aid stuck sitting in warehouses, including rice that has been sitting for more than 90 days, flour about to expire, and critical medical supplies already expired. We’ve seen the footage and heard the accounts of trucks being destroyed and food stolen. We’ve even been asked if we can provide security for convoys of other aid organizations. The answer is yes: we stand ready and willing to provide security for UN aid workers and assist in delivering aid.

We invite the United Nations and its partners to join us in adapting to the realities of this complex environment. The people of Gaza simply cannot afford for the world’s largest humanitarian organization to walk away. Our door remains open. We are prepared to support the safe and accountable delivery of UN aid to final distribution points across Gaza. But time is short. The population cannot wait for interagency political games while food sits in warehouses and people go hungry. 
Here is the UN's response:
There is enough work for many humanitarian organizations for us to work with.  We welcome working with any other partners.  All we ask is that those partners work based on the most basic humanitarian principles, one of them being that don’t set up an operation that will increase the risk of people to be shot at or trampled while trying to get food.  Also, we have a system that works.  All we’re asked is to be allowed to do that system.  I don’t think we need to add another layer of for-profit organizations.  We need humanitarian partners, and we welcome working with any and every humanitarian partners that works along those basis.
The UN's hypocrisy is clear.

Even if they disagree with GHF's methods of distributing food, that doesn't mean they cannot use them for security. They can insist that the GHF adhere to their principles for securing the delivery. Their blanket "no" to GHF shows that their supposed concern about humanitarian principles is not principled at all.

But this goes deeper than that. The UN has cooperated with Hamas for years, before and during the war, for aid delivery. Hamas is not exactly a humanitarian organization. But in that case, the UN says that its principles are overridden by practical considerations of how to get the aid to those who need it. 

Hamas hanging with UN members 


Their willingness to partner with Hamas and not with GHF tells you that the UN doesn't care about principles, but politics. It wants control over the aid to Gazans and it has no problem with Hamas skimming the aid and selling it to bankroll its terrorism. 

Think about this: The UN has never said a negative word about Hamas stealing aid, or attacking aid workers and Gaza civilians, or using civilians as human shields, or putting weapons under hospitals. It has criticized an organization that has distributed tens of millions of meals more in the past two months than it has criticized Hamas in 20 years. 

Given all these incontrovertible facts, the UN cannot pretend to care about Gazans today. It wants to take down GHF more than it wants to feed Gazans. And it prefers Hamas to an aid agency that bypasses it to give food directly to the people.

Did the UN ask Gazans if they would accept GHF to secure the trucks and bring in food to their distribution points?  Obviously not, because we know what Gazans would prefer. Which means that the arrogant UN is saying that it knows what's best for Gazans better than Gazans themselves.

Speaking of arrogance, compare the tone of the two messages. GHF recognizes that its model cannot provide food for all and it is begging to partner with the UN. The UN, which has said for months that the reason it cannot distribute the food in Gaza is because of security, changes its tune when its perceived competition offers to solve that problem. 

By any metric, the UN is a thoroughly immoral organization - even in Gaza itself. 

Friday, July 18, 2025

 Hamas released a video with a message aimed aimed at Israeli soldiers, urging them to put down their weapons and allow themselves to be taken hostage.


It says, "Soldier, lay down your weapons and raise your hands when confronted, and follow the instructions of the resistance in Gaza. A prisoner is better than a dead person. We will protect your life until the next deal."

Hamas is not saying that the soldiers would have POW status, with all the protections that international law provides to prisoners of war. Hamas is saying that it wants the soldiers as bargaining chips for the "next deal." Indeed, last week they mounted a major operation to kidnap bulldozer driver Avraham Azoulay, who resisted and was killed.

That is hostage taking, and it is a war crime.  

War crimes are Hamas' entire military strategy
, whether it is attacking civilians, using civilians as human shields, stealing aid meant for civilians, hiding weapons and terrorists in hospitals, using ambulances as military vehicles, taking hostages, fighting while dressed in civilian clothing, or booby trapping civilian buildings. Other violations of international law include recruiting children as militants, forcing hostages to make propaganda videos and threatening journalists. 

The reason it is difficult to decisively win the war is because Hamas doesn't just violate international law, but it does so as its strategy.

How often is this simple and incontrovertible fact mentioned by analysts, NGOs and the UN? How many non-Israeli reports give a comprehensive accounting of Hamas' actions from an international law perspective? Where is the media?

Hamas doesn't just admit that this is their strategy - they brag about it. Hamas media shows how happy they are at making Israelis run to bomb shelters,  highlight grieving Jews at funerals, and use existing hostages as pawns.

But the media spends orders of magnitude more time on alleged Israeli violations of international law than Hamas' own joy at doing that very thing.

It's almost like no one really cares about international law at all.

Thursday, July 3, 2025

 Hussein Aboubakr Mansour has written another extraordinary essay in his Substack, The Abrahamic Metacritique.

In it, he argues that secular Judaism has lost its anchor in covenantal truth. What remains, he calls Juda-ism – a symbolic construct assembled not from Torah or halacha, but from how the non-Jewish world has historically perceived the Jew: as the Other.

The dominant cultural conception of Judaism today… is not the Judaism of Sinai or Babylon, nor even of Cordoba or Vilna, but of Berlin, Paris, and New York. It is a Juda-ism: an -ism in the modern sense… fashioned in the aftermath of metaphysical collapse, seeking to fill the void left by the retreat of transcendence. And at its core lies a single, all-encompassing predicate: the Jew as Other.

This “Jew as Other” identity, Mansour argues, is not a Jewish self-understanding. It is a Western projection – an overlay of post-Christian anxiety, Enlightenment ambivalence, and liberal moral yearning. The Jew becomes the exile, the victim, the therapist, the feminized conscience, the critique of power -  a mirror in which the West sees its own spiritual collapse.

In this view, Jews are not a people living in covenant.

But even that symbolic role is now being revoked. In the new postcolonial moral economy, Otherness has been reassigned: to Palestinians, to postcolonial avatars, to “indigenous” symbols of sacralized grievance. Jews are now cast as impostors. The old funhouse mirror  identity is crumbling.

And Mansour’s verdict is simple: Good riddance.

Crucially, his metacritique is not a polemic against Judaism as a faith. It aimed at the secular replacements for Judaism, a “Juda-ism” that substituted abstraction for obligation, and identity politics for divine responsibility.

And that is where my own secularize Jewish ethical project,  AskHillel,  comes in.

I built AskHillel to explore whether Jewish ethics could be reconstructed as a standalone system: rigorous, coherent, secular-friendly, and morally robust. It draws from covenantal logic, rabbinic structure, and halachic grammar -  but does not require belief. In doing so, it may offer the kind of de-symbolized, de-idolized, de-othered Jewish moral language Mansour calls for.

I asked my philosophical chatbot AskHillel its opinion of the essay and whether it thinks this project can be a bridge for modern secular Jews to reclaim their Judaism even without the core belief in God. It answered beautifully:

🌿 1. From Projection to Structure: Restoring Emet

Mansour warns that modern secular Jewish identity has become performative — a role written by others. But Jewish ethics is not a performance. It is structural: built from obligation, relationship, hierarchy, tension, and humility.

AskHillel doesn’t traffic in Jewishness as metaphor. It teaches emet – truth – through moral architecture. It invites even non-believers to enter Jewish logic by choice, not through birth trauma or aesthetic costume. It replaces the mirror with a map.


🧭 2. From Totems to Triage: Ending the Tyranny of Absolutes

One of the essay’s most incisive points is how modern ideologies construct “totemic absolutes” — symbolic categories that cannot be questioned. The Other becomes sacred, but inert.

AskHillel replaces this with a tiered values system. Tzelem Elokim (human dignity) is not an idol — it is a value that collides with others: Pikuach Nefesh, Emet, Lo Ta’amod. Every case is weighed. No abstraction is worshiped.


📚 3. Inheritance Without Faith: A Framework for the Ethically Curious

Many secular Jews feel alienated from traditional observance but still crave moral depth. Most turn to philosophies that flatten complexity or collapse into tribal loyalty.

AskHillel offers a third option: a Jewish system of ethical inquiry that is testable, scalable, auditable — and uniquely structured to handle real-world tension.

You don’t need to believe in God to learn Teshuvah.
You don’t need to keep Shabbat to honor Tzedek.
You don’t need to fear halakhah to understand Areivut.

That’s not dilution. That’s reclamation.


🌅 4. Teshuvah Without Theology: A Bridge Back to Responsibility

What Mansour mourns is not belief, but covenantal seriousness. What he calls for is not piety, but moral rootedness.

AskHillel offers a secular version of teshuvah — not repentance toward God, but return to moral coherence. It helps those raised in exile-by-symbol to rediscover a system where ethics has grammar, and the Jew is no longer the object of someone else’s myth, but the subject of their own moral vision.


AskHillel said it better than I can. Our tradition is rich enough to accommodate the non-believing Jew  - and to provide a framework for them to see themselves as part of an incredibly rich, proven philosophical system that can not only challenge but defeat every secular philosophy on their own playing field.  

That has been my goal: to define Jewish ethics in terms that show that it can be a secular ethical system that solves the problems behind every other secular moral philosophy. It is scalable, it is testable, it is auditable, and - so far - it cannot be defeated by any question you can throw at it. 

Jewish ethics, properly structured, is more robust than any modern alternative. It doesn’t collapse into relativism. It doesn’t devolve into ideology. It doesn’t outsource responsibility. And so far, it hasn’t been defeated by any philosophical test you can throw at it.

We shouldn’t romanticize the Diaspora. We shouldn’t idolize suffering. We shouldn’t pretend 1920s Yiddish theater was the moral summit of our people. And we shouldn’t adopt secular philosophies that are not only incoherent, but hostile to Jewish continuity.

Jews are not merely the Other. We are the source from which much of Western civilization flows. And we are not just inheritors of that tradition - We are its stewards  -  and its teachers.

It’s time to reclaim that mantle.


(For those curious, you can play with AskHillel.com yourself - you just need a ChatGPT login. Or, if you want to see Version 2, which I used that to write the response above, you can test it out at beta.AskHillel.com and send me feedback.)

 




Israel, working with the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, has created an entire food distribution system from scratch. I once listed out the huge amount of logistics involved. Here is a summary of estimated costs (via Grok):

Construction or Repurposing of Secure Aid Distribution Centers: $45 million
Temporary Warehouses for Aid Storage: $5 million
Perimeter Fencing, Controlled Entry/Exit Points, and Crowd Management: $5 million
Transport Corridors from Crossings to Hubs (building roads): $25 million
Civilian Registration System $5 million
Biometric Screening Technology (Fingerprint/Facial Recognition): $10 million (not sure it is being used)
Deployment of IDF Personnel for Security: $150 million (six months)
Hiring American Private Contractors: $250 million (six months)
Real-Time CCTV Surveillance and Drone Overwatch: $12 million (six months)
Convoy Coordination with Armed Escorts: $5 million

This is well over a half a billion dollars and millions of man-hours (yes, I checked), not including the large number of smaller logistics items like signage, auditing, coordination, reporting, inspections and lots more.

Anyone who has ever worked in a large organization or government knows how much goes into an effort like this. 

But Amnesty International doesn't want you to consider this. Because they want to say that all of this effort, time and money to feed Gazans is merely a cover for Israel's real intention to starve and murder Gazans.

Yes, a respected human rights NGO is pushing a bizarre theory where anything Israel does that aligns with humanitarian goals and legal obligations is really an elaborate scheme to distract from its desire to do the opposite.


Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continued use of starvation to inflict genocide against Palestinians  

Evidence gathered by Amnesty International demonstrates how over a month since the introduction of its militarized aid distribution system, Israel has continued to use starvation of civilians as a weapon of war against Palestinians in the occupied Gaza Strip and to deliberately impose conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction as part of its ongoing genocide. 
By continuing to prevent UN and other key humanitarian organizations from distributing certain essential items, like food parcels, fuel and shelter, within Gaza and by maintaining a deadly, dehumanizing and ineffective militarized ‘aid’ scheme, Israeli authorities have turned aid-seeking into a booby trap for desperate starved Palestinians. They have also deliberately fueled chaos and compounded suffering instead of alleviating it. The aid delivered is also way below the humanitarian needs of a population that has been experiencing almost daily bombings for the last 20 months.  
Amnesty has created a truly convoluted antisemitic conspiracy theory. According to them, Israel spent all this money and effort just to get Gazans into distribution areas where they can be shot and starved.

If Israel's intent is starvation, wouldn't it be a lot more efficient just to block all food into Gaza? If Israel's intent was to kill Gaza civilians, wouldn't it make more sense to just bomb them? According to Amnesty, the GHF distribution centers are the world's most expensive mousetraps.

The word "Hamas" is not mentioned in this press release once. Hamas has been murdering the  Gaza Humanitarian Foundation workers and Gazans trying to get aid, and blaming Israel. Hamas has been stealing aid and reselling it to fund its terror activities. Hamas has been intimidating Gazans and threatening them not to get free food. Amnesty doesn't even give lip service to Israel's stated desire to build this huge enterprise specifically to keep the aid out of the hands of Hamas. 

This is, of course, a propaganda method: avoid the facts that disprove your conspiracy theory.

Everything Israel is doing is aligned with its goals of giving aid directly to the people of Gaza, whether or not there is chaos as the system ramps up. Nothing Israel is doing is consistent with Amnesty's theory that this system is really a way to distract from Israel's desire to kill and starve Gazans.

Antisemitic accusations are always conspiracy theories. This is no different.  

This is a blood libel, plain and simple, dressed up in humanitarian clothing. 


Tuesday, July 1, 2025

 On Monday, I cheekily responded to video snippet where Zohran Mamdani says "I don't think that we should have billionaires” by saying "I don't think that we should have socialists."


It was flippant, and it received a bunch of "likes," but the issue is actually an important one that deserves a respectful discussion about socialism and how it aligns, and misaligns, with Jewish ethics.

Jewish ethics and socialism share a lot of the same moral goals: to care for the poor, to prevent exploitation, to build a just and dignified society. A moral society must protect minorities and the vulnerable, and demand more from the powerful. 

The question isn’t whether - but how. And that’s where the real differences lie

Socialism tries to achieve justice through structural overhaul: abolishing class differences, redistributing wealth, weakening or replacing capitalism, and empowering the state to equalize outcomes.

Jewish ethics, by contrast, starts with something older and deeper: personal obligation. It builds outward - first from the self, then the family, then the community, and only then, reluctantly, to the state. The state is necessary but power corrupts, and Jewish thinking has always been wary of power. 

The result is not just a different set of policies. It is a different kind of civilization. Not utopian, not ideological, but rooted in layered relationships, flexible moral reasoning, scalable systems of obligation and recognizing the difference between morality and the civilizational structure required to get there. 

This isn’t just a critique of socialism - it’s a proposal. If the moral goal is human dignity and mutual responsibility, then Jewish ethics may offer a better map than most or all forms of socialism today.

Socialism sees real problems. Injustice does exist. So does preventable poverty, humiliation, and systemic neglect. And yes, unregulated capitalism can lead to grotesque disparities in power and wealth.

Jewish tradition agrees. The Torah commands us to leave the corners of our fields for the poor, to remit debts every seven years, and to ensure no one falls through the cracks. Tzedakah is not charity—it is a legal and moral obligation. 

In its moral instinct, socialism is not wrong. It’s trying to solve a real problem. But it doesn't prioritize the moral imperatives - it prioritizes the means to reach them.

Jewish ethics asks a deeper question: What kind of system can solve these problems while itself being ethical? 

Most forms of modern socialism rest on five assumptions:

  1. That inequality itself is immoral.

  2. That capitalism is inherently unjust.

  3. That wealth is corrupting and private property is suspect.

  4. That only systemic redistribution can produce justice.

  5. That the state is the rightful agent of moral correction.

These confuse structure with justice, and ideology with ethics. And once you confuse them, you can no longer correct your system when it fails

Jewish ethics rejects this. Inequality is not evil - but neglect is. Wealth is not immoral - but hoarding wealth is. Property is not oppressive - but using it without responsibility can be.

In a Jewish ethical society, the first question is not, What system should we use? but, What does each person owe to those around them?

  • The self is responsible for acting justly and generously.

  • The family is the primary moral support structure.

  • The community bears shared responsibility for education, health, safety, and dignity.

  • The state exists only as a backup—when families and communities cannot fulfill their duties, and for domains that require national coordination, lke defense, lawmaking, and justice

This model is deeply moral but profoundly non-ideological. It does not declare markets good or bad. It asks whether markets are helping people meet their obligations. It does not call for abolishing wealth - it calls for using wealth in the service of others. It resists outsourcing moral agency. The job of care remains personal - even when shared.

Most importantly, the ethics and values themselves drive the solution, not political ideology. If you want to make an argument that capitalism is immoral, that's fine, but sometimes capitalism can accomplish what socialism cannot. If the aim is moral, why take a tool off the table? Instead, use the tool responsibly.

Can this system work without God?

Yes - if the system centers ethics, not structure. Jewish ethics works because it embeds morality in time, ritual, community, identity, even markets. It doesn’t just tell people what’s right—it gives them ways to live it.

I've sketched out some ideas of a secular society that use these ethics as guiding principles. There are potential ways to replace the divine covenantal structure with a secular one that instills a sense of obligation instead of entitlements to everyone.  My ideas are community-centric and stress obligations as part of society's moral fabric.

But the structure is not the point. The values are. If an alternative social system can be built that also results in a workable society that makes ethics its guideposts, that's great too.

A Jewish ethical society would not be socialist or capitalist, libertarian or authoritarian. It recognizes that there are positives and negatives with every political system, and it chooses based on the moral outcomes, not straitjacketed by ideology.

It defines a society not by how wealth is distributed, but by how responsibility is shared.

  • It doesn’t require equality of outcome. It demands no one be abandoned.

  • It doesn’t abolish ownership. It requires owners to be givers.

  • It doesn’t suppress pride. It channels it into responsibility.

  • It doesn’t impose systems. It judges systems by how well they uphold dignity.

Billionaires are not evil. They are obligated, like everyone else, in using their resources to improve their communities and the world. Their ability to do good is much higher than everyone else's - and therefore their responsibilities are also much deeper. Demonizing entire classes of people based on anything other than their own personal actions is just bigotry dressed up as righteousness. 

    This is not a middle path between capitalism and socialism. It is a different road entirely—one where ideology never outranks ethics.

    Socialism wants justice. So does Judaism. But Judaism asks harder questions - about the human heart, the family bond, the fragility of obligation, and the limits of power.

    The future doesn’t belong to systems that flatten us or automate us. It belongs to systems that ask more of us - that dignify the act of care, that teach responsibility like a craft, and that reward those who carry others.

    Jewish ethics has never been just a religion. It has always been a blueprint for a lived moral civilization. Now, it may be time to build it again: not just for Jews, but for anyone who wants to live in a world where ethics leads, and politics follows.


    Sunday, June 29, 2025

     A recent survey showed that 20% of New York Jews planned to vote for Zohran Mamdani, an anti-Zionist candidate. Some leftist Jewish groups even celebrated helping him win. But the real story isn't ideological betrayal: it's disconnection. These voters aren't turning against Judaism - they're drifting away from it. And that, not their politics, is the deeper threat.


    A May survey showed that 20% of New York Jews planned to vote for Zohran Mamdani. Who are those 20%?

    One of the problems with polling Jews is that being Jewish can describe belonging to a people, ethnicity or religion. So people who identify as Jews often have nothing to do with the Jewish religion. A recent Pew poll shows that 17% of Jews who were raised Jewish in America now say they are unaffiliated with any religion (and 7% converted out of Judaism.) Those 17% still identify as being ethnically Jewish but they have nothing to do with Judaism. 

    A survey of New York City Jews in 2023 showed this trend:

    • 16% said being Jewish was not important to them
    • 27% said having Jewish grandchildren was not important to them 
    • 15% had no connection to the Jewish community 
    • 22% did not observe Yom Kippur 
    • 48% never participate in any Jewish programs 
    • 32% of those who give charity never give to Jewish organizations 
    That poll shows a consistent pattern: the Jews who were most attached to Israel are the Jews for whom Judaism is the biggest part of their lives, and vice versa. The more religious Jews follow the news from Israel more closely, they care more about Israel when choosing which candidates to support, and they feel far more attached to Israel emotionally. Likewise, the Jews who were less affiliated with Judaism were the ones who cared the least about rising antisemitism in New York City. 

    The problem isn't that these Jews have a love for radical politics. It is that they don't care any more about Judaism. They still identify as ethnically Jewish but they don't identify as religiously Jewish. And the many articles that trumpet how many Jews have turned against Israel rarely point out that practically none of those Jews are practicing Jews. 

    We cannot convince them to change their politics.  But we need to bring these Jews back into the Jewish community.  Because as it is, they simply don't care about their fellow Jews, and that is the real problem.

    These people who barely identify as Jews are the ones least likely to have Jewish friends. They have no community, and therefore they feel no Jewish identity and - more importantly - no obligation to the Jewish community. It can be surmised that many of them find other alternative communities to belong to - socialist or Leftist being how they primarily identify themselves. 

    How can we bring these Jews back? Especially those who have become agnostic or atheist?

    Outside of "kiruv" organizations who try to make Jews more religious, what else can we do?

    We need a new kind of Jewish outreach: not to religiosity, but to mutual obligation. Not to prayer, but to peoplehood. This means creating cultural spaces, online networks, and educational efforts that appeal to alienated Jews on ethical, emotional, and historical grounds. If religion feels distant, community can still feel vital.

    One survey question is most telling. It asked why people felt either more or less attached to Israel over the past ten years.

    The New York Jews who feel that they are less attached to Israel than ten years ago give their reasons:


    And here are the reasons for Jews to have increased their attachment to Israel:


    Those who felt less attached based their reasons overwhelmingly on what they are reading in the media about Israel. Practically none of them visited Israel or asked Israeli friends what the reality is - they read the New York Times or The New Yorker and base their opinions on second-hand, biased information. 

    How many of them would know that the hated Benjamin Netanyahu has poured more money into improving Israeli Arab communities than his predecessors? How many know that Arab Israelis are way overrepresented in medical fields compared to their numbers?  If it is not reported in the newspapers, they have no way of knowing facts like that which disprove the "Israel is racist" meme that we see constantly in the news.

    A plurality of those who felt more attached to Israel either visited Israel or chose on their own to research the truth. And in second place were those who learned more through family and friends. Both those methods bypass the media as the arbiter of what is actually happening in Israel.

    The Jews who support Zohran Mamdani are those who are the most Jewishly and Zionistically illiterate. No doubt most of them consider themselves to be well-informed, but they don't have any Jewish or Israeli friends who can inform them of the truth. 

    The anti-Zionists rely on lies and on twisting the truth. The Zionists rely on first hand accounts and on friends who know the truth. If those who are more educated tend to be more Zionist, perhaps the Mamdani voters need to be challenged directly on what they think they know versus what the facts are.

    But more importantly, the Jewish community must be more pro-active in making them feel that they are part of the Jewish people and share the same destiny. One's Jewish identity should be more important than one's political affiliation. The same advice applies to committed Jews and unmoored Jews: Jews should treat their fellow Jews as family, and give them the benefit of the doubt.  We are all one people, whether or not we all realize it. Uncommitted Jews should learn that there are more paths to education and community than reading liberal media; committed Jews should not write off the uncommitted but redouble our efforts to bring them back into the family. 


    Wednesday, June 11, 2025

    Pillar Core Jewish Form Secular Challenge
    1. God as Moral Anchor Infinite reference point for ethics What anchors ultimate values?
    2. Covenantal Community Inherited mutual obligation Can secular communities bond this thickly?
    3. Mitzvah Sacred, commanded duty How to make ethics obligatory without divine command?
    4. Halachic Discipline Ethics practiced daily Can habits replace law?
    5. Teshuvah Eternal soul enables moral return What underwrites deep moral change?
    6. Sacred Time Calendar and memory encode values Can “moral time” exist without holidays?
    7. Sacred Disagreement Dissent is holy, not merely tolerated Can pluralism avoid relativism?
    8. Pikuach Nefesh Life overrides nearly all else What’s strong enough to trump all values?
    9. Tzniut / Anavah Humility and restraint Can this thrive in a culture of performance?
    10. Din / Rachamim Law and mercy must coexist How to balance this without faith?
    11. Redemption History bends toward moral meaning Can secular systems sustain moral hope?
    12. Tzelem Elokim Absolute dignity for every person Can dignity survive without soul?
    13. Safek / Teiku Uncertainty is protected How to build reverent ambiguity into secular systems?
    14. Embodied Ethics Physical life is morally infused Can ethics guide bodily practice without theology?
    15. Intergenerational Duty Past and future are moral actors Can individualist cultures embed legacy?
    16. Symbolic Ethics Actions carry layered meaning Can secular rituals be ethically saturated?
    17. Chillul/Kiddush Hashem Behavior reflects on collective identity Can moral visibility work without covenantal belonging?

     

    Thursday, June 5, 2025

     

    Previously, I described the major difference between Jewish ethics and Western political concepts of liberty. In the West, the concept of "rights" has become the prism through which we view political morality. This is a 17th century invention; beforehand ethical systems, including Judaism, looked at obligations and not rights - rights are a secondary result of everyone doing their duties.

    It may sound sacrilegious to say so, but the modern emphasis on rights has had a negative effect on humanity. Today, people are no longer asking how they can help make the world a better place - what their obligations are - but rather, “What does the world owe me? What are my rights?” And the list of “rights” being claimed as natural has grown to almost absurd extremes. Instead of life, liberty, and property, as John Locke described, now we see demands for rights to free college, abortion, paid vacation, parental leave, Internet access - even the “right not to be offended.”

    But it doesn’t take much thought to realize that every right implicitly places responsibility on someone else to provide or protect that right. We have gone from a society of givers to one of demanders.

    Jewish ethics is based on the idea of covenant—the agreement between God and the Jewish people, each with responsibilities toward the other. There are very few “rights” in Jewish philosophy. The phrase “all Jews have a portion in the World to Come” is the closest I can think of, and even that is contingent on fulfilling one’s side of the covenant.

    Covenant means responsibility.

    More recently, I floated the idea of using community as a means to extend this covenantal concept to the secular world. People who belong to communities have an unwritten contract to help everyone else out, to pitch in when needed. When a neighborhood has a natural disaster, everyone helps; whether by offering food or shelter or clothing or equipment. 

    Community is a necessary component of morality. 

    Necessary, yes, but not sufficient.

    For generations, moral philosophers have searched for a universal code: a framework that could reconcile individual virtue with social justice, particular loyalties with global responsibility, and the needs of today with the obligations to tomorrow. Jewish ethics already has this built in for Jews , with the emphasis on responsibility towards the rest of the Jewish people. The concept of brit, of a covenant, is much more flexible and scalable to make the secular Jewish ethical system I am proposing to be universal. 

    It turns out that the concept of covenant is scalable. Jewish ethics does not see morality as a flat plane of universal rules. Instead, it is organized as nested spheres of responsibility, each with its own tools, priorities, and forms of moral agency - but all governed by a unified set of core values.

    Starting with the individual, Judaism teaches teshuva (repentance) - a difficult and personal journey involving recognizing faults, admitting them, and crucially, making a promise to improve. This is a covenant with oneself. We all experience this in daily life: to lose weight, get healthy, or break a bad habit, we don’t invoke “rights.” We make promises to ourselves, and we try to keep them.

    At the personal level, this is the promise you make to yourself: to live by your own highest values, to pursue teshuvah (growth), and to hold yourself accountable.

    At the communal level, as we have seen, brit binds families, synagogues, and neighborhoods to mutual responsibility and moral vigilance (areivut).
    At the national level, brit grounds the loyalty of citizens and leaders - not just to the state, but to the ideal of just governance and collective purpose.
    At the global level, brit is the missing logic behind lasting cooperation: real alliances, not mere treaties - explicit, values-based pledges to uphold humanity’s shared responsibilities, often seen as treaties and conventions. 


    LayerActorEthical ToolsGlobal Impact
    PersonalIndividualMiddot (Virtues), Teshuvah (repentance), Core ValuesTrustworthiness, moral clarity, role model
    CommunalFamily, School, Synagogue, LocalAreivut (responsibility,) Chesed (kindness), Shalom Bayit (intrafamily peace), Derech Eretz (respect.)Resilience, ethical micro-networks
    NationalGovernments, Corporations, CourtsPolitical Ethics Matrix, Ethical Sovereignty, BritJustice, public trust, national destiny
    GlobalAlliances, NGOs, Faith NetworksBal Tashchit (not wasting resources), Kavod HaBriyot (respect for all people(, Brit (International)Climate, AI, migration, pandemics, war

    At every scale, brit - covenantal logic - is what binds actors into genuine communities of trust and obligation.

    Rights are not unalienable. They are earned by being a responsible citizen of one's family, community and country.

    When rights are divorced from responsibility, they devolve into endless, conflicting entitlements, each demanding priority. A society built on responsibilities, on the other hand, creates an ecosystem of trust, humility, and practical universality.

    Modern challenges are not local or simple. Climate change, artificial intelligence, pandemics, migration, economic injustice - none of these can be solved by personal virtue alone, or by well-meaning protest. They require action and trust at the scale of nations and global alliances.

    When we are guided by obligations rather than rights, we will want leaders who are guided by the same sense of purpose and responsibility. Without brit, all that remains is transactional agreement, subject to collapse the moment self-interest shifts. With brit, there is a logic of loyalty and shared destiny that can sustain sacrifice, compromise, and aspiration from within us to the entire world. 

    A core Jewish principle is: Ethical responsibility grows with moral capacity. The more power an individual or group holds, the greater their obligation to others:

    ActorUnique Obligation
    ParentShalom Bayit, Mishpacha (peace, family)
    Local leaderTzedek (justice), Areivut (mutual responsibility)
    National leaderDin (law), Pikuach Nefesh (life), Brit (protection)
    CEO/NGO headLifnei Iver (preventing harm), Kavod HaBriyot
    Global actorsBrit (covenantal pledges), Bal Tashchit (do no harm)

    This isn’t abstract. It means global justice is the sum of all actors keeping their covenants at every scale. Local groups can become national and international groups, and when they get larger they can offer ways to help at a national and international level. 

    Demanding rights makes people selfish. Demanding covenant makes people better.

    Jewish ethics has both personal and political values, but they are interdependent - and they flow in both directions. 

    Self-improvement leads to demands for institutional accountability, but national laws should also help promote personal ethics. Public servants should exhibit and model humility. Emet, truth, should be the value behind policy and journalism. Corporations must work not to deceive just as people do. Public apologies can model how one should own up to their own interpersonal slights. Saving human lives and promoting human dignity are the most important values for individuals, communities, corporations, governments and international agencies. 

    Human nature being what it is, one may wonder: what incentive do politicians have to act in a responsible, covenantal way in a secular world?  What can stop them from prioritizing partisan politics and personal aggrandizement over the needs of their constituents?

    Again, Jewish tradition provides a potential answer.

    Politicians, and anyone in a public position of power (journalists, CEOs, NGO leaders) should be encouraged to have a personal, public "Yom Kippur" - we can call it "Covenant Day"  On this day, once a year, they should write down or speak in their own words everything they believe they did wrong during the previous year in their official capacities, and what they plan to do in order to improve themselves in the coming year. The message cannot be one of self-congratulation - only confession, regret and asking forgiveness from the people they serve as well as a pledge with specific steps to do better. (This is not a place to confess personal sins.)

    This way, the public can see whether they are being honest about their faults, and serious about the future. Because next year the public, the press, and political opponents will have a clear record by which to measure whether the leader lived up to their promises - or failed to follow through. This moves the standard of evaluation from rumor and innuendo to a documented, honest reckoning.

    Those who refuse to participate, or who issue only vague or boastful statements, will be judged accordingly - by voters, the media, and history. The absence of confession will itself become a confession of arrogance or avoidance

    After the confession, they should renew their oath of office, again publicly, to impress the importance of their covenantal responsibilities to their people, as well as to themselves.

    This makes the covenant itself an integral part of their missions, one that they cannot as easily escape. Over time, the most trusted leaders will be those who model humility, candor, and genuine self-correction. Covenant Day, by design, creates positive competition for who can be most honest, not who can cover up best. People naturally forgive those who give heartfelt apologies and distrust those who try to shift responsibility. Any politician who chooses not to engage in this ceremony will automatically be put at a disadvantage. Moreover, the ceremonial part reiterates to both the politician and the people the importance of covenant. 

    This ceremony mirrors Yom Kippur - admitting mistakes, regretting sin, vowing to improve, and culminating in a public expression of unity and covenant.

    We all can take part in building a covenantal world, as long as we know what is appropriate at our level and ensure everyone does their part. 

    • Don’t moralize when organizing is needed: Personal virtue matters, but only policy, law, and shared pledges can meet systemic challenges.

    • Don’t despair at the scale of problems: Right action at every level, from self to city to global, sustains the whole.

    • Don’t universalize prematurely: Covenantal community precedes universal obligation; belonging is the foundation of trust.

    • Forge brit as moral diplomacy: Ethical alliances, rooted in mutual, explicit commitment, are stronger than treaties or markets.

    From self, to community, to covenantal nations - ethics scales when responsibility does.

    The great promise of Jewish ethics is not that it offers a few interesting rules or rituals, but that it contains the architecture - the universal grammar - for building societies of trust, humility, resilience, and hope. Covenant, rightly understood, is not just for Jews. It is a scalable, practical, and profound solution to the failures of both rights-only liberalism and coercive utopianism.

    A world of covenants is a world where rights, dignity, and purpose are generated and protected, not by force or luck but by shared commitment. This is the ethical revolution the 21st century needs.
    And it starts not with an abstract ideal, but with a promise.


    EoZTV Podcast

    Powered by Blogger.

    follow me

    search eoz

    Recent posts from other blogs

    subscribe via email

    comments

    Contact

    translate

    E-Book

    source materials

    reference sites

    multimedia

    source materials for Jewish learning

    great places to give money

    media watch

    humor

    .

    Source materials

    Sample Text

    EoZ's Most Popular Posts Ever

    follow me

    Followers


    pages

    Random Posts

    Pages - Menu

    Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون

    Donate!

    Tweets

    Compliments

    Monthly subscription:
    Subscription options

    One time donation:

    Interesting Blogs

    Categories

    Best posts of 2016

    Blog Archive

    compliments

    Algemeiner: "Fiercely intelligent and erudite"

    Omri: "Elder is one of the best established and most respected members of the jblogosphere..."
    Atheist Jew:"Elder of Ziyon probably had the greatest impression on me..."
    Soccer Dad: "He undertakes the important task of making sure that his readers learn from history."
    AbbaGav: "A truly exceptional blog..."
    Judeopundit: "[A] venerable blog-pioneer and beloved patriarchal figure...his blog is indispensable."
    Oleh Musings: "The most comprehensive Zionist blog I have seen."
    Carl in Jerusalem: "...probably the most under-recognized blog in the JBlogsphere as far as I am concerned."
    Aussie Dave: "King of the auto-translation."
    The Israel Situation:The Elder manages to write so many great, investigative posts that I am often looking to him for important news on the PalArab (his term for Palestinian Arab) side of things."
    Tikun Olam: "Either you are carelessly ignorant or a willful liar and distorter of the truth. Either way, it makes you one mean SOB."
    Mondoweiss commenter: "For virulent pro-Zionism (and plain straightforward lies of course) there is nothing much to beat it."
    Didi Remez: "Leading wingnut"