Tuesday, April 18, 2023
8:06 AM
Elder of Ziyon
No comments
Yom HaShoah is not only about remembrance, but about ensuring that such atrocities will never again happen.
Yet we are seeing the groundwork for it happening in front of our eyes.
Nazi antisemitism did not only rely on racism against individual Jews as untermenschen. They also railed against Jews as a nation.
And their propaganda against the nation of "Judah" bears a chilling resemblance to the anti-Israel rhetoric that is becoming mainstream today.
From United Press, December 1938:
Is this any different from current accusations that the "Israel Lobby" controls America?
The "Judah" terminology was used in the earliest days of the Nazi regime. And some of those exactly mirror the anti-Israel rhetoric of today.
In 1933, Hitler partially justified boycotting Jews - by accusing "Judah" of racism against Germans! (Dayton Daily News, 31 Mar 1933):
There is no difference between saying "Judah is racist" and "Zionism is racism." The modern antisemites may pretend they are anti-Nazi, but they sure mimic Nazi rhetoric.
One of the early Nazi slogans, which was enthusiastically taken up by Western antisemites, was "Perish Judah." It spread quickly from 1935 in Berlin:
...to 1936 in London:
The British Fascists used the "Perish Judah" phrase so much that they began marking Jewish houses and shops with the initials "P.J." to encourage others to smash the marked doors and windows as late as 1943.
"Perish Judah" has morphed into today's "Death to Israel."
The connection between "Judah" and Israel is seen even more explicitly in this report from 1935:
There is a clear line between Nazi railing against "Judah" and today's obsessive hate of Israel. Boycotts of Jews in the 1930s are now called BDS.
Then, Jews were accused of controlling Western nations politically; today Zionists are accused of the same thing.
Mobs screaming "Perish Judah" in Berlin have become mobs screaming "Death to Israel" and "Death to Jews" - still in Berlin.
No, we are not at the death camp stage. We are merely at the stage where Jews are being murdered for being Jews in Israel and some Westerners are justifying those terror attacks as well as laying the ideological groundwork to make such attacks appear legal and moral. The Western antisemites of the 1930s didn't need to convince the larger British and US populations to hate Jews - they only needed to to associate Jews with theft and malice and Jewish supremacy enough so that casual observers would start to believe a little of it. They were able to sow enough doubt as to whether Jews were worth the effort of defending - when public defense of Jews could subject one to attacks. They wanted to sow some doubt as to whether Jews were worth the effort of saving.
Today's anti-Zionists insist that they are not antisemitic. You know who else made that claim in 1933?
Just because the analogy isn't perfect doesn't mean it isn't valid. As the expression goes, history doesn't repeat itself - but it does rhyme. The parallels between classic antisemitism and today's obsessive hate to Israel is obvious to anyone who opens their eyes. If Israel wasn't filled with Jews, it would get roughly the same worldwide criticism that Belgium does.
We might not be at 1939 yet, but we are in the same decade. And while today's antisemites might not be building death camps, some of them are building a nuclear bomb - with the same lack of response by the West as during the Holocaust, partially because of the constant stream of antisemitic propaganda that ends up affecting national leaders enough to favor inaction over action.
Never Again shouldn't be an empty slogan. So far, it has been.
Related Posts:
Russian equestrians to bypass sports sanctions for 2024 Olympics - by competing as Palestinians The Palestinian Authority is helping Russia bypass sanctions on their competing in sports. It has given Palestinian citizenship to several of the top Russian equestrian team members, so they will have a chance to compete… Read More
"Jewish academics" write an open letter against the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. Another larger group responds.From the EU Observer, November 3: Israel is trying to gag its critics by formally labelling them as antisemites in the UN, Jewish academics have warned, but the EU Commission says there's no cause for alarm. Some 128 scho… Read More
12/13 Links Pt2: Landes on Why Leftists Embrace Islamist Ideas about the West; The history of the media intifada against Israel; Brandeis Center: FBI Report Grossly Understated Antisemitic CrimesFrom Ian: Richard Landes on Why Leftists Embrace Islamist Ideas about the West Richard Landes, chair of Scholars for Peace in the Middle East (SPME) and author of Can the "Whole World" Be Wrong? Lethal Journalism, Antisemiti… Read More
Palestinian prime minister insists that Palestinian films must be anti-Israel propaganda - and soon it will be policy Palestinian prime minister Mohamed Shtayyeh met with Palestinian filmmakers on Tuesday and gave them one message: produce pro-Palestinian propaganda. He stated, "The strength of our narrative in the face of poisonous fund… Read More
24 years since the PLO fooled Clinton into thinking they amended their charter On this day in 1998, President Bill Clinton was bamboozled by Yasir Arafat into believing that the PLO had changed its charter. The very moment of the sham was captured in the photo above, as a roomful of Palestinia… Read More
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)