Monday, December 19, 2022
7:08 AM
Elder of Ziyon
No comments
From the 1902 edition of Encyclopedia Britannica:
Less than a decade after the term was coined, the writer - Lucien Wolf - recognized clearly that modern Zionism was a direct "lineal heir" to the longtime Jewish attachment to the Land of Israel since the Jewish nation's first exile.
Today's scholars find such an idea anathema, because it would mean that the Jews have a historic tie to the land, and too many modern academics want to separate Zionism from Judaism. But at the time, it was obvious to all, Jew and non-Jew.
Wolf was an anti-Zionist himself. He lobbied against the Balfour Declaration and co-founded the anti-Zionist League of British Jews. His political opinion caused his blind spot, both in this article and his article on antisemitism in the encyclopedia, where he fervently believed that Jew-hatred was a thing of the past and the world was more enlightened - dooming Zionism to failure.
His predictions were fatally wrong.
Yet even as the antisemitism that he confidently believed had been receding was proven to be not only resilient but far deadlier than anyone could imagine, he didn't have the honesty to admit his mistakes.
If there were fewer Jewish anti-Zionists in England in the 1920s and 1930s, it is possible that many more Jews could have been saved from the gas chambers.
Related Posts:
“Who’s a Jew?” Hits the Headlines, Again (Vic Rosenthal) Israel’s Supreme Court decided a few days ago that conversions to Judaism by the Reform and Conservative movements in Israel must be recognized by the state for the purposes of the Law of Return. Until now, the state… Read More
University of Toronto History Department advertises a terroristThe University of Toronto Faculty of Arts and Science - Department of History is advertising this event happening today: On the lower left of this picture we see Ghassan Kanafani: Kanfani was a terrorist. He was the spo… Read More
Terror groups welcome "impartial" ICC investigation - because they know the ICC is on their side Yesterday, the International Criminal Court said it was opening an investigation into possible war crimes by Israel and Palestinians. The statement - under a photo of prosecutor Fatou Bensouda with a sign saying "D… Read More
03/03 Links Pt2: Israel has become a wedge issue due to progressive left - David Friedman; Has Ben Rhodes Made the Descent into Antisemitism?; NY Dems’ BDS Debate Shows the Power of the Woke LeftFrom Ian: Israel has become a wedge issue due to progressive left - David Friedman He said that “there was not a place to land this issue in a way that would have great consensus” during the time he served as ambassador – fr… Read More
How will the Abraham Accords affect the self image of Israel's Arabs? (Daled Amos) In his 1986 capsule review of Raphael Patai's book, The Seed of Abraham: Jews and Arabs in Contact and Conflict, John C. Campbell concludes: The author draws some personal conclusions of his own that seem unduly optimisti… Read More
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)